+V Vɤ ɨlx ڱ E i E + + ɶɴi ʺx V x ɨlx ڱ E +iMi vx E Jɮnɮ E i E , nx E vɨ =x Sxi nx Sɽi E {ڴ =iiɮ |n E MJ{֮, ɽɮVMV, {bx, ɺi Vx{n E n ɽ ڱEx EB i +V E iɮJ iE BE E vx E Jɮnɮ ɨlx ڱ {ɮ ɮEɮ uɮ xɽ E M< *

{ڴ ɽ M ɮEɮ l* Sɽi E ʴMi ɹ E +Ec E nx E {] {ɮ M * {ڴ E nx ɨlx ڱ {ɮ vx E Jɮnnɮ xɽ <* Vɺ Vx{n SxE +i ɽ vxɤɽֱ ɽɮVMV Vx{n + vx E Ex E {U nx Vix Vɱi Zx {c , =E hx < nx E +n xɽ E Ei* +V bVɱ ڱ r x Ex + MɮҤ Vnڮ E Eɮ E icE J n * ɽ Ei E +iɮɹ]Ҫ Vɮ 40 |iɶi r < , <ʱB x bVɱ E ڱ 40 |iɶi giɮ Ex E Eɨ E * xɴɮ, + Jɮҡ E ɱ E E]< E n Sɱ + E ɱ E +< E n Sɱ * +V Ex E +{x ɱ E Ji Jʱɽx iE Vx E ʱB + vx E Jʱɽx Vɮ iE Vx E ʱB, E +< E ʱB {ɨ{ɺ] E ]E] iE VMɽ bVɱ E <iɱ Ex {c + < bVɱ ڱ r x +V Ex E ʺli E xʶSi i {ɮ SɮɮE J n * +V +ɴɶE i E xɨ {ɮ ɽ ]E +{ɮ] E ciɱ E icx E ʱB =x V n Ex E vɨE n * <xɺ ɽ Ex Sɽi E +{E V V n Ex E vɨE E ɹ , ɽ vɨE E ɹ n x SʽB* n ɮ ]E +{ɮ] + ɺ +{ɮ] x ɽ iɪ E ʱɪ E V E +n Vx E Eɨ EM i Ex Sɽi E <xE V VMɽ E {c VɪM + Vɤ Vxi Vx-ʴp E ɺi {ɮ =iɮ VɪM i <xE ʱB |ɶɺx Sɱx ʶE VɪM* <ʱB ɽ vɨE ɮ ɹ E <iɱ n x SʽB* ]E +{ɮ] E {c E <x ɨZx SʽB, Ex E nn E <x ɨZx SʽB, +ɨ +ɨ E nn E <x ɨZx SʽB + ɤE nn E ɨZE ʡ <x + iiEʱE i {ɮ bVɱ E ڱɴr E {ɺ x SʽB + iiEɱ < ڱ r E {ɺ E ʡ nx E ɮ n E xi+ E `E < ɨɺ x{]x E ʱB BE {ɹ] hxi iɮ Ex SʽB*

+{E vɨ ɽ Ex Sɽi E +V bVɱ E ڱɴr x Mƴ E MɮҤ ʽ E +Ү iE ɦ E |ɦʴi Ex E Eɪ E * Z ɽ Ex ixE ES xɽ E +Ү E >{ɮ <E E |ɦɴ {c + MɮҤ E >{ɮ <E Vn |ɦɴ {c + SE +Ү E {Ivɮ , <ʱB <xx +Ү E {Ivɮi E |nʶi Ei B bVɱ E ڱ ɮ r Ex E Eɪ E + =E nֹ{ʮhɨ +V {ڮ n E +n =ɮE ɨx +x M *

ɦ{i ɽn, + c r M* + x ɨ x<E V E ɪx E +Jɤɮ {g E ɽ B.{.V. + Eʺx E nɨ r Ex V * xʶSi i {ɮ bVɱ ɮ nxE

... (ɴvx)

{]ʱɪɨ + |EiE M j ( ɨ x<E): x Eʺx E ʱB xɽ E

... (ɴvx)

+Jɱ ʺƽ : Eʺx + B.{.V. E ʱB +Jɤɮ x {g , Ei E +Jɤɮ Mɱi i U{ M<

... (ɴvx)

+{x ʤb E]i E i E * ɽ Ex Sɽi E +V V bVɱ E ڱ r BE x< ʺli =i{xx < , =ɺ ɮ SV E nɨ giɮ E +ɺɮ {ɹ] i {ɮ nJɪ n + ɽ giɮ MɮҤ ESɮ E c +n iE E |ɦʴi Ex E Eɨ EM* bVɱ ڱ r B ʴɹɪ xɽ VɺE ɽ {ɮ Uc n VB* c ʴxɩi{ڴE Ex Sɽi E n +{E xҪi ɡ l, +{E S ɡ l i +{E Vxn E +x E |iI Ex SʽB l* Vɤ Vxn {ɹ] i {ɮ + =ɮE +{E {I + Vi + +{ < nx ` Vi i ʡ ɤE ɪ i + =E n bVɱ E n xhǪ i i ɽ +{E EijE En x Vi* Ex +x ɱ {ʮʺliɪ ix +E]ڤɮ E i E 12 V +{x bVɱ E ڱ r Ex E Eɪ E, xʶSi i {ɮ {ʮʺliɪ, ɽ iɴɮh +{E n E iɴɮh Px E Eɨ Ei * +V +{E vɨ ɮEɮ M Ei E ɽ bVɱ E ڱ E M< giɮ E iiEɱ {ɺ x E Eɨ E* +V bVɱ E ڱ E giɮ x ɨ{h Vx-VҴx E =uʱi Ex E Eɨ E * <x ɤn E l +{E vxɴn ni *

xɴɱ E ɪ (iɨg): ɦ{i ɽn, + V bVɱ ڱ r E M< , ɮEɮ E ʱB ɽ E`x ɱ l* E {ʮʺli ɮEɮ E ɽ ɱ x {c, <E >{ɮ nx + nx ɽ SS * ɦ xxҪ n E xxҪ ɨ x<E V E iɮ V x] V MB =xɨ ɽ {ɹ] E Mɪ E V <]xxɱ +ɱ E] , =ɨ Vɺ |Eɮ giiɮ < + +ɱ {ڱ E P] gE +ɽ ʺli {ɽSx E n ɮEɮ E ɽ nְ ɱ x {c* xʶSi { < |Eɮ E ʺli n E ɦ V ɮEɮ + n E ɦ {I E M E ʱB Sxi E ʴɹɪ , Ex < ʺli {ɮ Eֱ ʨɱE n ɨVɺ l{i EE B ɨɪ < E`x ʺli E ɨx Ex SʽB, ɽ {ɮ E Vxi E UcE, Sɮ iɮ , ɽ ʴSɮ =ɮ E +B *

ɦ{i V, + xxҪ {ɪɱ] ɽ x xɹ{I ɴ EU Ex E |ɪix E + =xx {ʱǪɨ] SS E E {ʱǪɨ] iɪ Ex E i E * =xE < xɹ{I ɴ E ɮɽx Ei , Ex 50 ɱ E n E +Vn E ɨɪ 45 ɱ i =xE ɮEɮ ii , Ex iɤ =xx E B xɽ S, Ex + ʴ{I , i xɹ{I ɴ ɱɽ nx Sɽi + Ei E {ʱǪɨ] ɤ EU iɪ VB, ɽ ɽi +SU i * <E ɨlx Ei *

ɦ{i ɽn, +xiɮǹ]Ҫ Vɮ 124 bɮ 163 bɮ ESS i E nɨ g * =E +xֺɮ Sɮ {B E MɦM x 30 Һn r < * Z ɽ nJE +ɶSɪ i E Vɤ 30 |iɶi bVɱ E nɨ r E ɮEɮ E nְ + E`x ɱ E +ɱSx i Ei , Ex V ɮEɮ x, Vɽ + Jc ɽ n 30 |iɶi E Vɪ b.]..E EB 100 |iɶi E r E * x i ɽ SʽB l E bVɱ E 30 |iɶi r E +x{i ɺ E EB 30 |iɶi E r E Vi, Ex xɽ E Mɪ + {S {B EB E lx {ɮ nMx EE 10 {B E n Mɪ* +{E vɨ < nx E ɨI ɮEɮ Ex Sɽi E < {ɮ xɪjh x SʽB + <E >{ɮ vx n Vx SʽB E 30 |iɶi E lx {ɮ ɺ E Eɪ 100 |iɶi E g n Mɪ* Sɽi E B xɽ x SʽB*

ɦ{i ɽn, <ɨ <{] b], BE<V b], 䱺 ]E, ɦ E Vɨ EE ɽ V bVɱ E |< g< M< + JɺE VɺE ɮ Ex {ɮ {cx ɱ + ɽ V nְ xhǪ + , < {ɮ {xʴSɮ Ex i +{E vɨ ɮEɮ +x֮v Ex Sɽi , iE Ex {ɮ V ɽ ɽi c ɮ {c , <ɺ ɽi nx i E< x E< xi xE = ɽi nx E |ɪɺ Ex SʽB, B xi , Ex < i E ɡ Ex Sɽi E V ɮEɮ Vɺ |Eɮ Vxi E , ɽ `E xɽ * n V ɮEɮ < |Eɮ Vxi EM + +ɱ {ڱ E P] < |Eɮ gi M, i Ex + n E +ɨ +n ֮ iɮ ɮ Vi M* <ʱB xɴnx E V E Vxi xɽ Ex SʽB + Vxi >{ɮ =`E <E xEɱx SʽB*

ɦ{i ɽn, + xM h V x E, =xɺ Ex Sɽi E V ʺli n E , ɽ ʺli ʤɽɮ E * ɽ b]E] Vɺ]] x 30 |iɶi bVɱ giiɮ E +vɮ {ɮ 100 |iɶi Eɪ gx E Eɨ E * Vɤ nx +i , nx SS Ei , i +ɱ {ڱ E {E P] E {]x E ʱB ɮEɮ x V nְ ɱ ʱɪ , < {ɮ ʴSɮ Ex SʽB + ɮEɮ +{ұ Ex Sɽi , MVʮ Ex Sɽi , +Oɽ Ex Sɽi E BE ɮ ɽ +{x < ɱ {ɮ {xʴSɮ E + V Ex x , Ex , Vnڮ =xE >{ɮ V ɮ {c , =ɺ = ɽi nx E ʱB Sɮ {B EU P]x E E{ E* Vɽ Exp ɮEɮ +{ұ Ei ɽ {ɮ ɽ nJx SʽB E V ɮEɮ E VʮB V Vxi + =xx 30 |iɶi E lx {ɮ V 100 |iɶi Eɪ gx E Eɨ E , ɽ xɽ Ex SʽB*

ɦ{i ɽn, Mƴ E Vxi Mxi xɽ Vxi + x < Mhi E ɨZi E +ɱ {ڱ E P] E Eɮh Eɪ E 100 |iɶi gɪ Mɪ * +{E VʮB ɮEɮ ɽ +x֮v Ex Sɽi E V ɮEɮ +x֮v , JɺE E n + ʤɽɮ V 100 |iɶi Eɪ gɪ , =E Eɱ <iVɨ x SʽB iE BE ɨE xi x E*

+{E vɨ ɮEɮ MVʮ Ex Sɽi E ɽ bVɱ E g B nɨ E ɮ {xʴSɮ E* l Eʺx i, V E Ex x E ʱB , V + xxҪ n x SS E E Mƴ M n Vɱi , n{E Vɱi , =ɨ {cx ɱ Eʺx i E nɨ E |Eɮ E r x , B ʴɹ E ʱB M Ei B il +{E |i +ɦɮ Ei Ei B, +{x i ɨ{i Ei *

E֨ɮ ɪɴi : xxҪ ɦ{i V, +{E vɨ Bx.b.B. E ɮEɮ ʮE] Ex SɽM E bVɱ E EҨi V r E M< , = i֮i {ɺ ʱɪ Vɪ EE <E v |ɦɴ Ex {ɮ i {c , =E l-l n E +ɨ Vxi E >{ɮ {c * B {ʮɽx E vx V bVɱ Sɱi , Vɤ +{x bVɱ E EҨi g< i ɦʴE E ]ƺ{] E ʱE E Eɪ gx {cM * Vɤ Eɪ gM i =ɺ ɦ ɺi+ E EҨi r M + =E ɤɺ ֮ |ɦɴ B M {ɮ {cM V xi-Vnڮ EE BE nx 40 50 {ɪ Ei * +VʴE Ex E ʱB =xE ɺ E vɨ nںɮ vx E vɨ n Һ E] Vx {ci * = Vnڮ Eɪ nE =xE {ɺ V SM, ɽ Jt ɨOɪ Jɮnx E ʱB Eɡ xɽ M EE <E v |ɦɴ Jt ɨOɪ E ɺi+ E nɨ {ɮ {cM Vɺɺ =xE ʱB Jt ɨOɪ Jɮnx ʶE VɪM*

+{E vɨ ɮEɮ E ix Sɽi E <ɺ {ɽ +{E 13 ɽx ɮEɮ Sɱ + = nx Vɤ +{x ɺi+ E EҨi g<, = ɨɪ Vx Sɮ V ʴvx ɦ E <Ex B i =E <ix ֮ |ɦɴ {c E E< V ii +{E l xE M<* +{E ix Sɽi E ix iɮJ E i E +{x bVɱ E EҨi r E * n <Ex E nx +{x bVɱ E nɨ r E i i ɨZi E +V V +{ ii {I ` B , ɽ x ` i + +{ ʴ{I xVɮ +i* <ɨ E< E-֤ɽ xɽ E ɮiҪ Vxi {] E xii V Bx.b.B. E ʨɱ-Vֱ ɮEɮ Sɱ , B ɮiҪ Vxi {] E ɮ +Eɮ E Vi E ɽ ʤVx Eɺ E {] *

+{x bWɱ E EҨi Vɺ iɮ E< Mx r E , =E {U Vɰ EU x EU +{E bj E l xVɮ +i * +ɨ Vxi +Eɮ ɽ Ei E <Ex E nx Vx c-c ʤVx Eɺ E M E +lE ɽM E +{x <Ex c , V <Ex Ji B, =x ɪn {ɽSx E ʱB +{x 3 iɮJ E i E bVɱ E EҨi r E * ɨZi E <ɺ +ɨ xMʮE E xEx M, Ex E xEx M Ex c-c ʤVxɨx E xEx xɽ x ɱ * n +{ +lE ij E ɮ Ei E P] E Ex + n E +lE ʺli E iɮ vx nx i +{ɺ ɽ ʮE] E n ʴɱʺi E ɽi B SV VxE +ɨ xMʮE Ex EU x-nx xɽ * bVɱ E EҨi r Ex E VB n +{ ʴɱʺi E ɺi+ {ɮ E< Mx ]E M ni i = P] E ɮ{< =vɮ E Ei l* Ex E n +{ +{x Vn {ɮ +c , +{ ɽ ɽں E E +V +{E <E xEx xɽ M Ex n {S ɱ {ɽ ʡ <Ex MB i +{E ɽi ɮ xEx M, ʡ +{ ii xVɮ xɽ +BM, ʴ{I xVɮ +BM*

<ʱB xxҪ ɦ{i V, +{E vɨ ii {I E M ɽ ʮE] , ɱE Bx.b.B. ɽi P]E B V Eɡ nJ + Vɺ Ij SxE +B , ɽ E Vxi =xE Pɺ] , =xE |ɴE E E +{ S{ E ` , +{E ƽ Jx SʽB* Bx.b.B. ɽi P]E n n V֤x bVɱ E g < EҨi E ɮ Ex i Sɽi Ex nںɮ iɮ ɽ Ei E +iɮǹ]Ҫ Vɮ bVɱ E ڱ E r E vx JE ɮEɮ E ɽ ɱ x {c* ɮEɮ E ɽ ix SʽB E +iɮǹ]Ҫ Vɮ bVɱ E ڱ E r <* V r < l, = ɨɪ +{x ɽ r E xɽ E? V <Ex ɨ{i Vi , = i +{ bVɱ E ڱ r Ei * Z B Mi E +{x ɽ ɱ VxiE En ʱɪ + ʤVx Eɺ E ɪn {ɽSx E ʱB ʱɪ , Ex E xEx {ɽSx E ʱB ʱɪ , +ɨ xMʮE E xEx {ɽSx E ʱB ʱɪ *

ɦ{i V, +{E vɨ {x: Bx.b.B. E M ʮE] , ɮiҪ Vxi {] E xii Bx.b.B. E V ʨɱ-Vֱ ɮEɮ Sɱ , =xɺ ʮE] E +{ ɮEɮ {ɮ nɴ xB, |vx j V {ɮ nɴ xB iE bVɱ E ڱ V r < , = {ɺ ʱɪ VB +xl ɮiҪ Vxi {] E l-l Bx.b.B. V + P]E n , =xE n֤ɮ SxE +x ɽi ʶE VBM* Z Mi E +{ i {ɮ Vɰ vx nM* <x ɡW E l + Vn ɨɪ x i B, +{x Z x E ɨɪ n, <E ʱB +{E vxɴn ni *

SHRI P.H. PANDIAN (TIRUNELVELI): Mr. Chairman, Sir, on behalf of the All India Anna DMK, I would like to place a few facts and appeal to the House to direct the Government to withdraw the diesel hike raised on the 5th October.

At the outset I would like to state that on the 5th October, the care-taker Government headed by the Prime Minister was functioning.

Whether a caretaker Government can take such a major policy decision has to be viewed seriously by the House. The Minister who made the statement hiking the diesel price has been voted out of office. On 5th September, we faced the general elections. On 5th October, the diesel price hike was announced by the Minister, that is, on the eve of counting. Sixth was the counting day.

We all know that electoral promises are not enforceable in law. You can make any promise to the people to get votes with sugarcoated words. After the people have cast their votes or their votes are in the ballot boxes, the people have to abide by the decision of the Government. I would like to state at this juncture that when Shri Charan Singh was the Caretaker Prime Minister, it was challenged before the Calcutta High Court in the year 1980 whether the Caretaker Prime Minister can function as a full-fledged Prime Minister. I could see that after the fall of Shri Vajpayee's Government, he was functioning as a full-fledged Prime Minister. Prior to that, I think, he was functioning as the caretaker Prime Minister.


[NEXT PAGE]