ɦ{i ɽn x Ex n n , Vn xɽ M* EU i E E ɨ{i E nM* +{E ix Sɽi E V ɮ +xiʮE ɴɺl , V ɮ |ɶɺx E |hɱ , V =xxi + ֮I E ɴx ɨV +x SʽB, ɽ xɽ * <ʱB {ɽ =E >{ɮ Eɨ Ex {cM + +{x |ɶɺx E ƴnxɶұ xx M Vɺɺ ɮ V ƴvxE ڱ =xE +iMi nɴʺɪ E +ɺl x , ɮ BE x * +V ɨV E +n V <]-BEx , V =E +xiɮ-Ƥv , Pɹ {ɮ +vʮi *

ɦ{i ɽn : ExEb EVB*

ʴ |Eɶ ɨ : ɮ ɨ{i E * +V ɱi ɽ Mi E VxiE ʺliɪ ViMi ɴx+ Sɱx M , i Vɤ {I{i M, Vɤ xɨx M, i Mɴi M + Vɤ E Sʮj M, i +iEn E ʱB +vɮ Jc M* <x i {ɮ M Ex E ɽi VɤnǺi +ɴɶEi *

ɦ{i ɽn : `E * + ɨ{i EʮB*

ʴ |Eɶ ɨ : ɽ ɽ E ɽ ɺj +B * ɽ BE{ʺɴ +ɪ * ɽ E xVɴx E Jɮɤ Ex E |ɪɺ E Mɪ * =xE ɱS n Mɪ , =xE vɨE n M< , Ex ɤɺ {ɽ < i E Jɱ Jx E V ɮ +xiɮǹ]Ҫ E]xi , =ɨ ɮ V ɮEɮ ɽ E iɮE ={ɱʤvɪ |{i E { , ɽ xʶSi i E +iEn E Jɱɡ BE +xiɮǹ]Ҫ ɽ x {BM + ʽxnֺix E +n ɴɺl E xɴVMɮh E {BM, i E =ɺ ɨvx ʨɱM*

ɦ{i ɽn : + ɨ{i EVB*

ʴ |Eɶ ɨ : ɮ, BE ʨx]* <E l BE i + E nx Sɽi E +V ɮEɮ E ɨx BE nɴ E ɽ {E =q䶪 E ʱB Eɨ E, Ex V E ɦ M Vxi E ʽxnֺix n + ʺVn E ɨɱ {ɮ ɨV E ʴɦVi Eɪ Mɪ , VxiE i E >{ɮ, =E nJi B E =n E Ei E +xɪ E ɴx, Vֱ E ɴx E E {BM* +Mɮ VxiE iɮ {ɮ c =q䶪 E E xɽ Sɱ Ei, +Mɮ E Eh =q䶪 {ɮ Eɪ Ex , i +{E ɽ +Mi E nx E +iEn E Jɱɡ V ɮ =q䶪 , =xɨ nEEi +BM* xʶSiɰ{ VxiE { + +vE xɴi{h =q䶪 E E Sɱx {cM + ɤɺ +vE Vxi |ɶɺx E |i, ɮEɮ E |i ʴɶɺ VMx E ɽi +ɴɶEi * <ɺ c i Ex Sɽi *

ɦ{i ɽn : E{ E lx Oɽh EVB*

ʴ |Eɶ ɨ : xxҪ ɦ{i V, +{E vɨ Mɽ j ɽn E i nx Sɽi E

... (ɴvx)

SHRI RAJESH PILOT (DAUSA): Every Member who is speaking is showing his concern. It is not that he has to get up and give suggestions only. Please take it seriously. Let them give their views very seriously. You are giving only five minutes in a discussion under Rule 193 which is not a proper thing. If there is shortage of time, please tell the House. If a Member were to speak for four or five minutes only, what can he talk about the Kashmir situation? If you do not give even five minutes to a Member coming from Tripura where the situation is so bad, how can he express his views?

Eix ɨɪ ?

ɦ{i ɽn : xɪɨ 193 E +vx n P] E ɽ i * =ɨ <xE {] E {S ʨx] E ɨɪ *

SHRI RAJESH PILOT : Please ask the House to extend the time. Kashmir is going through a bad time and you are ringing the bell every five minutes asking Members to give only suggestions. It is a serious situation. Please take it seriously.

ʴ |Eɶ ɨ : +V BE + i {ɮ M Ex E |ɶɺx + Vxi E S E V nڮ g * |ɶɺx E Jɱɡ E ESʮ E Jɱɡ, {ʱɺ E Jɱɡ Eɱ Vxɦɴx+ E =ɮ nx Eɡ * <ɺ Vxi |ɺxx * =E ɨvx ʨɱ * <ix nڮ nJ< {cx M E < {ɮ ʴɶi M Ex {cM*

ʴ |Eɶ ɨ Vɮ ɮ |ɶɺx + Vxi E S V nڮ , V Iɪ {ڮ xɽ B , =xE {ڮ EE = nڮ E ɮ Vɪ*

ɦ{i ɽn : + +{ ɨ{i Eʮ*

ʴ |Eɶ ɨ : xxҪ Mɽ j V, V ƴnxɶұ Ij , +{E +Mi Ex Sɽi E ɽ V ʴEɺ E EɪF , =xE {ڮ VMɰEi E l + Vxi E ɽM i B +{ M E {ɪ + ʽxnֺix E ʴvx E +n Vɤ +{ M E Vx ɴx + +ɺl {n E {ɪM iɤ +{E ʴɶ { <x n nn ʨɱM* +iEn E Jɱɡ c< BE +iɮǹ]Ҫ c< * ɽ Jɱ ɮ ʽxnֺix E ɨɺ xɽ ʱE {ڮ ʴɶ E ɨɺ * Z +ɶ E ɮ |ɪɺ ɡ ʺr M + +iEn E Jɱɡ BE xhǪE c< ViM*

1711 hrs.

|Eɶ h j{` (nʮ) : ɦ{i V, +V E ʴɹɪ ɽi MɨҮ + ɹ]Ҫ * ɨɪ E x E Vɽ EҮ E ɮ Vn i EM EE +iEn + =Oɴn {ڴ Ij Vn {E xɽ ʱE Vn Vɱn ְ + * +ɨ ʤx nx x + EU nx {ڴ Vɱɱɤn E , = E] E :-

` ɮ ɤɺ c nֶx +ɮE + ɮi + +{x ɤ ƺvx =x xɶx xx SʽB*'

< E l =xx ɮ n E Jɱɡ Wn Ucx E Bx E n * ɽ c< EҮ {U 50 ɱ Sɱ * E EU ɨɪ |iI { r i i E ɨɪ +iEn Sɱi i * <ʱB EҮ E ʴɹɪ E Eɱ +iEn E nɪɮ xɽ J Ei* {U 50 ɱ ɮ 29,151 ʺʴʱɪx + 5,101 Vɴx ɮ Mɪ + 2 Vɮ Ec {ɪ E ɨ{ii E Ii < * ɮ BE ʨj x iɪ E 64 Vɮ Ec {ɪ E JS + * 7 Vɮ >{ɮ {Eix Pֺ{` x Pֺ{` E + 20 Vɮ ɮiҪ E {Elx pɮ |ʶIh n Mɪ * Ex ɤɺ Vɰ i ɽ E ɽ r 50 ɱ Sɱ <ʱB <E +iEn E h xɽ J V Ei* <ɨ E rVʴɪ E +xֺɮ ʴɶ E n E{ ] Mɪ * BE, nɰ <ɨ Vɽ {ɮ <ɨ E iɮE + =xE Sɱi + nںɮ, nɰ * ɮi E nɰ E E h J Mɪ * ɽ E Vi E nɰ iɤ iE c< Sɱi M Vɤ iE E ɽ nɰ <ɨ {ʮii x Vɪ* <ʱB < ɺɱ E BE +iEn E ɺɱ iE ʨi xɽ J nx SʽB* <E ɽi Eɮh , Vɺɨ xɽ V>M* Ex EҮ E +Mɮ ʨɺɱ Vɪ i =ɨ x 1949 c< <* x 1965 c< <* x 1971 c< < + + ɱ EɮMɱ BE r + * x 1971 E c< E n {Eix E nM ɽ ` Mɪ E ɮi |iI { c< xɽ E Ei* +Mɮ EM i E ɽi xEx M* x 1971 16 nx E c< ɮiҪ xE x {Eix E n ʽ ʴɦVi EE BE ʽ E ij x n Mɪ * 92 Vɮ xE vE xE ɽ {ɮ +ɪ* <ɺ {Eix E ɽi vEE M* =x iɦ Vx x< E < n E JJɱ Ex E ʱB Vɰ E +iEn gɪ Vɪ*

j{` - Vɮ +Mɮ SɨS nJ VB i EҮ +iEn E { x 1974 ֯ + * ɮ xxҪ n Mɽ V j SE * = ɨɪ +iEn ɽi {ɮEɹ` {ɮ l + =xx <ɺ bұ E * <ʱB ɽ ɨZ VB E ɽ ɨɺ +ɨ +iEn + =Oɴn E h xɽ * ɽ BE r * +{ < Sɽ |E E, Sɽ +ɨ E, ɽ r Sɱ * =E l ƺvx V]x E Eɨ E* Mɽ j V E v< nx Sɽi E =xE EɪEɱ Vɰ EU E +< l* ɽ i Jɺ Sx E E Vɤ +iEn E +{x Eɤ x E Eʶɶ Eɨɪɤ nJi i c< Uc Vi * Vɤ c< ɮ Vi i n֤ɮ +iEn {ɮ {ɺ +ɪ Vi EE n 1997 + 1998 E +Ec {ڮ i nJ VB i {i Mi E 1997 + 1998 ɮni E x ֯ < l* EɮMɱ =E xiV * EɮMɱ ʴɡ Vx E n n֤ɮ +iEn gx EɮMɱ E ʴɡi E xiV * <ʱB BE-nںɮ Vc B + <ɨ ɤɺ c ʨE +<.B.+<. E * Vɤ +<.B.+<. E i Ei i E {ڮ n {E { nJx {cM* Vɤ {E { nJi i ɽ nJ< {ci E Sɽ ɽ =iiɮ |n , Sɽ ʤɽɮ E <E , + iʨɱxb, E + +w |n <xE Miʴvɪ g * V +Ec nB , +{x +{ ɽi ɪɴɽ E +<.B.+<. E Vɱ E iɮ ʤU SE * Eɱ +iEn E UcE +M n r E {ʮʺli + M< + Vɺ iɮ i Sɱi , <ix ʴɺ]E M< E E ɨɪ r E {ʮʺli + Ei * = ɨɪ +<.B.+<. E Vɱ, V < n ʤU + , ɽi JiɮxE ʤi M, ɽ +{x {֮x +x֦ɴ i * ɽ ɨZx E n {U |n ɮEɮ < ɮ MƦҮ i i +<.B.+<. E Vɱ +V iE <ix iV xɽ ʤU Ei l*

<iɽɺ E {xx =]x E ʱB ɨɪ xɽ Ex BE-n SV ix Sɽi * Vɤ x 65 E r + l, EɮMɱ E V n {ɺ , Vxx ɽi {ɮx E, n ɮ r + l - < Vɤ ESU r + l iɤ =x n {ɺ E x ʱɪ l* {ɺ E nB MB* =E n n֤ɮ x 65 r + i V {Ү + n {ɺ ʡ x ʱɪ* ʡ {ɺ E nB MB* ɽ ix {ɺ VxE VʮB Vniɮ +iE =E {ɺ-{ɺ E <E ɽ +i * ɽ V ɨɺ {n < , Sɱ , g , < ɨɺ {ɮ ɽi nx {֮x ɮEɮ x f< Eɨ E , <ʱB ɽ g * < i E ɨZx SʽB* ɽ Ex Sɽi E < BE r E iɮ {ɮ nJ VB, E ʺɡ <ix E < VxiE, +lE, ɨVE, ʶI + ɹ]Ҫ iɮ {ɮ

cx {cM* < Eɱ xB xɽ c Ei* +<.B.+<. E Ji Ex {cM* < +ʦɪx E BE xxɱ ʨɶx E iɽi x {cM* <ɨ |n ɮEɮ E ɽi + ʨE , <ɺ nڮ xɽ ] Ei*

+iEn + =Oɴn BE +lE i xɽ xx SʽB* x ɽ nJ E Vx-Vx VMɽ {ɮ +iEn i , ɽ {ɮ ɽi { JS E Vi + ɽ { EU i Eɨ Vi , EU =x +iEn E V Vi + Vɤ ɽ BE i x Vi i +iEn BE {ɮ E { i * <ʱB VɤE |Mi E ʱB { nx Vɰ , Ex < iɮ =E +ɴ]x x E Vɪ E ɽ iɮ +iEn E ɪn n* ɽi =nɽh n Ei , ɮ +iEn cx E 15 ɱ E +x֦ɴ * ɮi ʴɮv |{Mhb {Eix E M ɽi |ɦʴi i + =xE =xn gi * ɮ ɽ n֦M + ɽ ƺn x E-E nJ E B i E Vi E E-E Mi E nںɮ M V <E xM, SM E ɮ ɪ E +ɱSx ɮiҪ Vxi {] E ɮEɮ , ɽ ֺɱɨx ʴɮv * ɤ SV ɽ {ɮ {ɽSi + ʤɱEֱ Mɱi n <ɺ Vi , x Eɱ {Eix , =E ɮ ʡF xɽ , Ex n V EҮ E Vxi Vi , ɽ BE ɽi Mɱi n + E ɽ ffE < n E n Vɪ E ֺɱɨx ʴɮv , =xE Jɱɡ EɮǴ< EM, ɮ-ɮ ffE V ɽ E n Vi , ɮ Jɱ ɽ ɮ < ʴɹɪ E ʱB BE ɽi Mɱi SV *

BE i Ex Sɽi , V E t V x E E EҮ E Vxi x +iEn ƽ c ʱɪ * Ex EҮ E +ɱ +iEn + {Vɤ E +iEn EҤ-EҤ BE ɨɪ ְ B l, {Vɤ +iEn cx E +ɺɮ ʨɱ l* x ɽ nJ E +iE iɤ {x{i , VɤE ɽ E Vxi =E l ni + ɽ i E ɽ E Vxi +iEn ƽ c , Ex +{x >{ɮ <ix Ei {n xɽ E { E ɽ +iEn c* < E E ɨZx SʽB* <ʱB ɽ Vɰ E V M ɽ {ɺ ɽ V n Mɪ , =xE {ɺ x Vɪ Vɪ, +{x VMɽ {ɮ ɺɪ Vɪ, EE ɤɺ Vɰ SV +iEn cx Sx + Sx E ʱB E i SʽB + <ʱB V M xEɱ Mɪ , ɤɺ {ɽ |lʨEi nx {cM, =x M E {ɺ VE ɽ {ɮ ɺx E, EE M lxҪ M E Vxi *

+Jɮ i ɽ Ex Sɽi E EɮMɱ ɮ Vɴx E , =xE iM 1971 x {Eix E BE ɤE ʺJɪ l* ɽ ɤE ɽ 20-25 ɱ iE xɽ ڱ, Eɱ +iEn {ɮ M , Ex x< {g + M<, 25 ɱ E n ɽ 1971 ڱ Mɪ* EɮMɱ E r E, EɮMɱ ƽic Vɴɤ ʨɱ , nɮ =xE ɽ ɤE ʨɱM E |iI { c< xɽ Ex , +iEn E gɴ nx , <ʱB E BE ɹ]Ҫ ʨɶx xE <ɺ c< Ex {cM* ɽi-ɽi vxɴn*

V {ɪɱ] (n) : ɦ{i ɽn, {ɽ i +{E +ɦɮ * ... (ɴvx) Zɺ {ɽ x Sɽi ? +{ , Z <xE i Yx ʨɱM* +{ Zɺ {ɽ x Sɽ i *

ɦ{i ɽn, +{E +ɦɮ E +{x < ʴɹɪ {ɮ SS |ɮ E* x x i E l E EҮ EU ɨɺB , iɦ x ɽ ɴɱ =`ɪ * +V nx <ʱB SS E ɽ ɱi Mɮ + +Ec Mɮ * Mɮ , ɽ nJ E Mɮ * E Vɺ {ɮ ɽ E l, E ɽ x SʽB* E i ɱ SE V xMɮ E ʤɱEֱ h] , Mɱ SE {ɮ ɺ] B + +` +n ɮ Mɪ * < E l, `E E +iEn xɽ Vcx SʽB* < i E xi E EҮ E ɨɺ +iEn xɽ Vcx SʽB* EҮ E ɨɺ ʦxx + ɽ i `E , ɤ E `E = {ɮ ɽi vx Sx {cM* ɽ +E ɮEɮ E iEҡ xɽ *

M ɮEɮ * ɽ n E ɨɺ , Ex nJ E i E ɮEɮ x =ix SE xɽ nJ< <ʱB +{E S i Ex +B * ɽ SS< SS E , ɽ xɽ E ʴ{I ` <ʱB * ʺEʮ] V E M Vix {ɽ E ɱ xɽ ɮ, =ɺ Vn {U ɱ ɮ * < iɮ {U ɱ {ɽ E ɱ Vn +]E B * nɨ M E xE nJ, ɽ ʨʱ]] n Mb {ɮ EE ɮ E Sɱ MB* {ɽ ]V +, BE ɺ] + l, Vɺɨ ɮ Vɮ Vxɮ ɮ MB* ɽ xɽ Ei E B n {ɽ xɽ +, ]V B , Ex ʨʱ]] +ɨ E]xɨ] Sɱ VB + ɮE {ɺ Sɱ VB, BE ɮ Mɪ, nںɮ M Mɪ, ɽ Si E ʴɹɪ * x V xE E * V Mb {ɮ +, V ɮ ʺEʮ] E ɤɺ {Ji nV , =ɺ ʨʱ]] +n Sɱ MB <ʱB ɽ Si E ʴɹɪ * +V ʺEʮ] V {ɮ +]E g , ɮ < ɮ < ɱ 350 E EҤ =xE J , V x +{E BE =iiɮ {g * =xE {ɺ +vxE lɪɮ V , B.B.V., .B.V. , ʨɺ< E i Sɱx M , =xE ExEx ɮ V iɮ * Vɽ iE x E {g , =E +xֺɮ {ɽ {S ʨʱ]] E ɮE ɮ BE ɽn֮ Vɴx E֤x n Ei l, Ex + =xE +vxE lɪɮ + MB < Vɽ ix ʨʱ]] ɮE BE Vɴx E֤x n * <ɨ giiɮ * ɽ V {ɽ BE-{S E l, + BE-ix E Mɪ * ʺʴɱ EV+] +{E ʽɤ 1998 2261 l, + nɨɤɮ E ɽx Sɱ , +V 2350 M< * < Eɮh ɤɨ giiɮ * ʺEʮ] V {ɮ +]E Vn , ExEx Vn g , +ɨǺ Vn g , Pֺ{` Vn g * ɮ BE < + E l E v< ni E <xʡ]x {ɮ E M * ix Sɽi E ɽ 600 l x Pֺ{` E * Fɱ n E ʱB ɽɮ + Ei l + Jɤɮ n Ei l* {U + V {ɽ Pֺ{` xɽ + Ei l, +V =] * E{ɴc M <xʡ]x , V + {U M +x ְ MB * +Mɮ +{E 1965 E r n i {i M E Fɱ ɤɺ {ɽ Jɤɮ ni l E Pֺ{`B + MB + ʡ ɮ V EɮǴ< ְ E Ei l* +V M E xɽ Ei n , =x M E E iEҡ , ɽ nJx M* +V {U + V E <xʡ]x ְ M< * M V + {U +i + ʡ {ɽS Vi * ix ɽx +Eiڤɮ, xɴɨɮ + nɨɮ, B + Ei l E <x nx {ɺV n Vi l + M iɮ EE +]E E Ei l, <ɺ +M E ʱB ɽi ɽʱɪi Vi l* ɽ {ʮb i l Vɤ ɮ V {ʮɮ + Ei l* Vɤ ɡ {Pɱx Mi l i =xE {ɺV Jֱ Vi l, <xʡ]x g Vi l, Ex +V nJ E l Ex {ci E <x ix ɽx Pֺ{` g * < i E ɮEɮ E vx JE Sx SʽB* <E Eɮh E , nJ E l Ex {ci ɽ ɪx nx ɽi +ɺx E ɱi vɮ , EҮ + {֮x EҮ xɽ * ɽi ɮ x E Mɽ j V, Z nJ E ɽ EҮ n֤ɮ 1990 E ɱi x E {ɽS VB*


[NEXT PAGE]