1555 hrs.

xɴ ƺvx ʴEɺ j, ʴYx + |tME j il ɽɺMɮ ʴEɺ j (b. ֮ x V ): ɦ{i V, x ɽi vx nx < ʴvE {ɮ ɽ E x* + V xxҪ n l, =xɨ Mɨ ɽi Vn l Mɮ |Eɶ ɽi E l* Z |ɺxxi i E =xɨ Vix +vE Mɨ l, =ɨ EU ʽ +Mɮ |Eɶ E i i ɽ EU Vn Vxnɮ i* c E V E< i S xɽ Vi* =E ʱB iE SʽB, Vx SʽB*

ɤɺ {ɽ ɽ Ex SɽM, V i ɽ i< M< E < ʴvE ʦxx-ʦxx ɹ+ E +xִn Vx E Eɮh E{Ү<] E V =Px Vi , =E {i JE E xɽ Sɱi* + =E ʱB Eʶɶ E * |ɪix E E V E{Ү<] E EɪDZɪ =xE E{]Eh E, =xɨ ɮ ɨO J* +xִn Ex E ʱB JE E <VVi E Vɰi i * +Mɮ E JE E <VVi E ʤx +xִn + i ɽ E{Ү<] E =Px * + ɮEɮ JE E ɽ +ɶɺx xɽ n Ei E =E {ֺiE E E< +xִn EM i ɮEɮ = Jɤɮ nM* B ɮEɮ xɽ E Ei* Ex ɮEɮ < i E |ɤv EM E M E ɽ {i M VB E Ex-Ex {ֺiE E JE x ʱJ * +Mɮ E =E +xִn i + = +xִn JEE <VVi xɽ i = {i M VB, <ix ɴɺl E Ei * Ex =E ɮ En i JE E =`x {cM, EE ɨ{ii =E *

ɽn, E{Ү<] ɮEɮ E xɽ , ɽ = JE E + E{Ү<] EɪDZɪ E ng E * < ɮ ʴɶɺ ni E <E E< Sxi +{ x E* ɽ ɴɺl E VBM* E{Ү<] E EɪDZɪ E x ɪ xɮIh E l* Vɤ x iɤ =xE vɮ B ngEh xɽ +* V E`x< `E E VBM + =E ʱB EU En =`B V *

nںɮ i ɽ E M< E ƺEiE Miʴvɪ, +E]ESɮ +n E{Ү<] E =Px i * ɴɱ B E V-V E{Ү<] E nɪɮ gi Vi i Exx =E ʽɤ xi VBM* +Mɮ ʶEɪi +BM, iEҡ M i Vɰ =E xɮEh E ʱB E{Ү<] E +n EU + ɴɺl E VBM, Ex +V <E Vɰi xɽ + B ʶEɪi xɽ * , + BE ʨj x ʡ <b] E ɮ E E < E{Ү<] E Eɮh ɮ ʡ <b] E iEҡ VBM - ɽ i Ei * +Mɮ E nںɮ n E +vEɮ {ɮ |iɤv Mi i ɮ +vEɮ {ɮ |iɤv MM, <ʱB =E ɮ Sxi Ex E Vɰi xɽ * < i E nJ E <E V vɮ 42-B =E +l Mɱi ɨZ Mɪ n+ɱ ɽ +iʮEi ֮I ɮ n E JE E {ɮɨɺ n * niɮ * =vɮ |iɮI nM + |iɮI nM* +Mɮ E{Ү<] E =Px EM i nbi EB VBM, SE + ɽ{IҪ ɨZi , ɪɱ] xɽ ʱE ɱ]ұ] ɨZi , <ɨ +E +ʮE JE xɽ , 134 n

WTO

E n + Sx V ɽi n <E n x Sɽi , V + iE

WTO

E ɽ l

WTO

ʨɱ x E Eʶɶ E * ɮ ʨj x ɽi ʴɮv E l*

... (ɴvx)

MR. CHAIRMAN : Let the Minister conclude his speech.

b. ֮ x V : Sx =E +n Vx E Eʶɶ E *

... (ɴvx)

BE i =`< M< E x <E ʴɮv E l, , Vɰ E l* Z +{x ɮ ɹh n + Vɺ ɨɪ ɽ ʴɮv l = ɨɪ ɮ n E l E < i x, Ex Vɤ n x x ʱɪ, Vɤ ɮEɮ x v E , iIɮ E nB i ɽ Z n E >{ɮ + Mɪ*

uɮ Vɮ

16.00 hrs.

+ +{ < ɽ xɽ E Ei SE +{x ʴɮv E l + +V < n x +iɮɹ]Ҫ ɨZi E ʱɪ + + = ɨZi E Vɪ* +Mɮ ƺn < i E iɪ E n E <ɺ xE Vx i +M ʺli M* Ex +V V ʺli , +{ = ɨZi E +M , Sɽ x Sɽ, x x x* ɽ i Ex i ɽi +ɺx E

WTO

E ʴɮv E Vɪ Ex + =E ɨɪ xE Mɪ * E l Ex +ɡ ֪ + n x =E x ʱɪ, E E? ɤ x x ʱɪ* + i ʺli E +M gx E Vɰi * + Vɰi < i E E <E ɦ E =`ɪ Vɪ Vɺɺ E n E E E xEx * xxҪ ƺn b. Pִƶ |ɺn ʺƽ E ix Sɽi E Vɤ iE ɽ ɮEɮ , ɮi E ʽi {ɮ E< +Pi xɽ E Ei, E< ɮi E Jɮn xɽ Ei* ɮx ɽ ɽ ` ֪ , =xx B] ɮEɮ E E J ʱɪ* = ɮEɮ ` , VV ɽ < ɮEɮ i xɶSɪ ɮi E nʹ]Eh M* ɽ {ɽ ɮ + E ɮEɮ x <ix Wɤi E l B] +{x {I J* nxɪ E iɨɨ n x <E ɮɽx E + nxɪ E iɨɨ n ɮ l +ɪ* ɽ +{ Mɨ Sɽ V E Ex ɮ ɮx ɽ x xɮ + Mɮ nx iɮ +{x {I J* +{E ix Sɽi E +V E {ʮʺli ʴɶ E +lǴɴɺl c V] Vɺɨ x Eɱ +{x n E xEɱx ʱE nxɪ E nںɮ n E xEɱx * +Mɮ E E n E ɽ Exx x nxɪ E E nںɮ n E Ex {ɮ xɪ i <ɺ +vE Mɱiɡ E< xɽ Ei*

ɦ{i ɽn, =q䶪 ʱJ Vi E ɽ Exx +V E * <ɨ E< E xɽ E V ɨZi rE +vEɮ + , V ɨZi

WTO

+ , =E EU +xɴɪiɪ * +Mɮ =x iɮJ xɽ VɪM i +{E >{ɮ +xE |Eɮ E |iɤv MM, +xE |Eɮ E E`x< +ɪM* +{E >{ɮ {ʮE nʹ] + E`x< gx E Ʀɴx * <ʱɪ +{E ɽ xɶSɪ Ex {cM + ɽ xɶSɪ ɽ M E +{ = Exx B ƶvx E + l l +{E V +iɮɹ]Ҫ |iYɪ , +iɮɮɹ]Ҫ ɨZi , =xE {ɱx E* + ɽ E Mɪ E ɽ n ʽi xɽ + <E ʴɮv <ʱɪ E V E ɽ =q䶪 ʱJ + E

WTO

E E{ɱ<ƺ * ɽ E Mɪ E +ɮE E E +vEɮ x ɽ ɪx n E

India is on the watchlist.

Vɤ x {ɮh ʴɺ] E, iɤ Sʱɺ] * <b i Sʱɺ] {ɮ Ex <E ɽ +l xɽ E =xɺ nE E< Eɨ E *

ɽi vɨE n M< l* ɽ E Mɪ l E +{x {ɮh ɨ x ʱɪ, Ex M nM, +{E YxE E ɽ E nM* = ɨɪ < nx x E l E n ɮ ʴYx + ]ExɱV {ɮ Ex Mi , +Mɮ E YxE E ɽ Ei i +{x ɽ ɤ YxE E {ڮ ɴɺl nM, =x ֮I nM, xEʮ nM, |ɪMɶɱ+ Eɨ Ex E ʱɪ {ڮ ʴvɪ nM* Z < nx E ɽ ii ֪ Jֶ E Eɱ BE YxE E UcE E ɽ ɮi xɽ +ɪ + ɽ <ʱɪ +ɪ EE =xE ] Ji Mɪ l* +V +ɮE ʽi xɽ E ɽ ɮ YxE E ɽ ɽ xEɱ E + nxɪ E E< n ɽ xɽ xEɱ Ei* ɮ YxE +V Vɺ VMɽ , E E -E {ɮ xɽ * +V ʴn YxE {ɺ +i + Ei E +{E l Eɮ Ex E ʱɪ iɮ * +{E |ɪMɶɱ+ +{ɺ x nx Ex E ʱɪ iɮ * +{x YxE E Eɨ Ex E ʱɪ ɽ Vx Sɽi + BESV Ex Sɽi *

ɦ{i ɽn, +V {ʮʺli n + nE nJ nM E

+x ɱ iɤn < n E Uʴ B M Vɺɨ n E +i ɨx B M V {ɽ E x l - ɽ +{E Sx ni * V{ + ɮ Bx.b.B. E iɮ B |ɪix VɺE xiV +{E nJx E ʨɱM*

< iɮ xɽ ni * + BE xxҪ n x E E nںɮ E nɴ B E , nںɮ E nJE E nںɮ E xE E - ɽ ɮ +ni xɽ * ɽ =x M E +ni Vxx i-i V Eɱxɪɱ ɮ l, = {{ֱ ɮ n n* +SxE BE nx x< n E Exɺ] {] + <b V + iE < n E EU iEi E l n l, +OV E ʴɮv E l, +SxE +OV E {I M<* iɤ xiV ֦ɹ Sp E iV E Eii E Ei l, = n Ex E Vɰi * ... (ɴvx) =x i ɨZx SʽB E V E nJE ʽnֺix ɮ i E Ei l* BE Eɨɮb = Ei Ui J B ʨɪx E xS ` + l i =xɺ E x {U E < ɽ +{x Ui E J J , +{ i ʨɪx E xS * `

Don't you know, it is raining in Moscow?'

Vɤ ɺE ʮ i l i M ʽnֺix Ui Ji l* =x M E ɽ xʺEi Ei E nxɪ E nںɮ n E nJE E< Eɨ Ei * ɽ ɮEɮ + <E ɽM ɮi E Vɨx E nJE Eɨ Ei , ɮi E ƺEi E nJE Eɨ Ei + = Sx E ʱB |iɤr * ix Sɽi

... (ɴvx)

+{ E< Si x E* Z iɪ Mɪ E Ү, Ү, EҮ, ڮ + ]M <x ɤE ɮ ƮIh x SʽB

... (ɴvx)

.E.Vɡ ɮҢ (Mɱ =iiɮ) : BE U] EʮʡEx Sɽi *

DR. MURLI MANOHAR JOSHI: I am not yielding.

MR. CHAIRMAN : Shri C.K. Jaffer Sharief, please sit down. He is not yielding.

SHRI C.K. JAFFER SHARIEF (BANGALORE NORTH): Mr. Chairman, when you were there, they were yielding to you.

MR. CHAIRMAN: That is a different thing.

DR. MURLI MANOHAR JOSHI: I am not yielding.

SHRI C.K. JAFFER SHARIEF : Why?

DR. MURLI MANOHAN JOSHI: That is my right. At the moment, I am not yielding.

MR. CHAIRMAN : Shri C.K. Jaffer Sharief, please sit down. He is not yielding. After the reply is over, you can seek clarification?

SHRI C.K. JAFFER SHARIEF (BANGALORE NORTH): After the reply, what will be the use of it? It is relevant only now... (Interruptions)...He has said that a large number of people from other countries are coming here to share our knowledge, and the country has reached a stage that it need not depend on others. Is it the result of the tapassya of all these years or just three months after he took over?

DR. MURLI MANOHAR JOSHI: Yes, of course, it is the contribution of every Government, it is the contribution of people of India that now we have reached this stage.

+{E <ix {ɮx E ?

Vɮ Vxɮ (xɴii) ִx Sxp Jhbڮ (Mgɱ) : Vɡ ɮҡ ɽ +{E <xɡʮɮ] E{ɱE E ?

b.֮ x V: +{ B E ɨZ E <ɨ +{E E]Ҥڶx xɽ * {ɽ B] ɨ i ʨɺV Mv E Vɨx c Mɪ l* E i * +{E ɱڨ x SʽB

... (ɴvx)

V {ɪɱ] (n) : E ɮEɮ x +V iE n E ʽi ɱ E, ɽ V V x E n, V E =x xɽ Ex SʽB l* V ɮEɮ , ɤx n ʽi ɴ{ʮ J * Sɽ E<

... (ɴvx)

b.֮ x V: ɦ{i ɽn, n nx Sɽi E iji E 50 ɹM` {ɮ x BE ʡ x< l Vɺɨ {bi Vɴɽ ɱ x E +V iE n E ɮ |vx jɪ E Mnx E nJɪ l* <ʱB +{ >{ɮ ɽ +ɮ{ xɽ M Ei* +x ɮEɮ E Mnx E i E l, + iE V ɮEɮ

... (ɴvx)

SHRI PRIYA RANJAN DASMUNSI (RAIGANJ): It is not that he has done some favour. It is the part of the history... (Interruptions)

MR. CHAIRMAN: Hon. Member, please sit down.

... (Interruptions)

MR. CHAIRMAN: Please confine to the Copyright Bill.

... (Interruptions)

MR. CHAIRMAN: Hon. Member, please sit down. Some are copyrights of the Congress and some are the copyrights of the BJP. That is all.

b.֮ x V: nɺɨx V, vx{ڴE xɪ, Ex Vɤ +{E ɮEɮ i , iɤ +{ nںɮ ɮEɮ E ʤɱEֱ E]E J ni * =xE i xɽ xx Sɽi , =xE iɮ nJx xɽ Sɽi *

... (ɴvx)

<E iɮ vx nVB* x ɽ iɪ E E E{Ү<] E ɽEɮ ʨiɪ E ʴiiҪ ɽɪi nM* Vɺɺ ɨx JE E +vEɮ ֮Ii E* < Exx V ƶvx E V ɽ +iɮɹ]Ҫ iɮ {ɮ ɮ Exx `E VB, = xi `E E V * +{E ɽ ʴɶɺ nx Sɽi E ɽ +E B ʴvE <vɮ +ɪ M Vɺɨ E< B i xɽ V ɮi E ʽi {ɮ E +Pi Ei * E + ʴvE +{ E Ei E ɽ lc E M<* Ex <ɨ +{ nJM E E E< E xɽ * BE Ij E x <ɨ Eƺb E * <ʱB B ɨZi E nx ɴǺɨi < ʴvE E {ɺ EM + EEɮ, xɨi+ + JE E +vEɮ E ƮIh Ex E ʱB + +iɮɹ]Ҫ iɮ {ɮ ɮ Exx E xi Ji B, Vɺɺ E b{] x ,

EE ZMc x {ɮ ʡ V |F i , =ɨ ɨx JE E ʱB c E`x< +i * ɽ <x ɨɱ c xɽ EM EE ɮ JE EV * <ʱB ɽ Exx < nʹ] x , +iɮǹ]Ҫ ɨZi E x Ex E ʱB x + n E EEɮ, ʽiEɮ E ʽi x * <ʱB +{ɺ +x֮v E +{ < ɴǺɨi {ɺ E*

MR. CHAIRMAN : The question is :

"That the Bill further to amend the Copyright Act, 1957, as passed by Rajya Sabha, be taken into consideration."

The motion was adopted.

MR. CHAIRMAN: The House will now take up clause by clause consideration of the Bill.

The question is :

"That clauses 2 to 7 stand part of the Bill."

The motion was adopted.

Clauses 2 to 7 were added to the Bill.

Clause 1, the Enacting Formula and the Long Title were added to the Bill.

------

b. ֮ x V: ɦ{i ɽn, |ɺiɴ Ei :

"E ʴvE {ʮi E Vɪ*"

MR. CHAIRMAN : The question is :

"That the Bill be passed."

The motion was adopted.

--------


[NEXT PAGE]