<b>XIII LOK SABHA DEBATES, <i> Session II (Winter Session) </i> </b>
XIII LOK SABHA DEBATES, Session II (Winter Session) Friday, December 10, 1999/Agrahayana 19, 1921 (Saka )


Type of Debate: PRIVATE MEMBERS' RESOLUTION
Title: Discussion on the resolution regarding need to constitute the Board for all-around development of hilly states and hilly regions of the country, especially in the Himalayan Belt, so as to bring them at par with developed regions in the plains of the country.

TEXT :
1703 hours

MR. CHAIRMAN: The House will now take up the Resolution on development of hilly regions by Shri Maheshwar Singh. Before we take up the Resolution for discussion, we have to allot time for it. Shall we allot two hours time for the Resolution?

SEVERAL MEMBERS: Yes.

MR. CHAIRMAN: So, two hours time is allotted for this Resolution. Shri Maheshwar Singh may move his Resolution.

ɽ䶴ɮ ʺƽ (b) : ɦ{i ɽn, +{E +x֨i xɨx ɤn xV E{ |ɺii Ei :

"E < ɦ E i E n E {ɴiҪ V + {ɴiҪ Ij, ʴɶE ʽɱɪ Ij E ɴMh ʴEɺ E ʱB ExpҪ ɮEɮ uɮ BE b M`i E Vɪ iE =x n E ʴEʺi nx Ij E ɮɤɮ ɪ V E*"

n E ij B 52 ɹ +vE i Mɪ, Ex Jn E ʴɹɪ E +V {ɽc + Exn+ ɺ B M +{x Ij E ʴEɺ E ʱB VZ * Vɤ <x ʽɱɪ E Mn ɺ B EU hҪ lx {ɮ {ɪ]E xv Vi n E ʴʶɹ] Ei Vi i +E ɺ Ei E SɨS {ɽc ɽi Vn |Mi < , Ex ii ʤɱEֱ <ɺ ʦxx * +Mɮ ii E nJx i <x {ɽc E V +xn E Ij , Vɽ E M {ɽc + Exn+ ɺ B , +V ʴEɺ E nʹ] {Uci V * <ɨ E< n ɪ xɽ E |xiҪ ɮEɮ +{x ʨi vx E vx Ji B <x |n ʴEɺ E ʱB |ɪɺɮi * V E ʽSɱ |n E ɮEɮ ɹ |ɪɺɮi + iǨx ɮEɮ +{x ʨi vx E vx Ji B +vE +vE vx < {ɽc |xi E iɮ, ʽSɱ |n E iɮ n *

uɮ Vɮ

ɽ䶴ɮ ʺƽ Vɮ <ɨ E< n ɪ xɽ E V {ɽc |i +x ɱ ƺn , ɨɪ-ɨɪ {ɮ < xxҪ nx {ɽc Ij ɨxvi ʴEɺ E ɮ +{x ɨɺB =`i * Ex ɮ J <ix E E < xxҪ nx ɮ +ɴV MVE Vi * < ɨɪ {ɽc |i +x ɱ ƺn E J, +Mɮ Mɱi xɽ E i ɽ MɦM 29 , ]x P] ɱ iɱE <E +iʮEi *

ɽ i E ɮi ɮEɮ x ɨɪ-ɨɪ {ɮ +xE VxB x< * V ʽ Bʮ bɱ{ɨ] |Oɨ, ]x P] bɱ{ɨ] |Oɨ, xl-<Ǻ] Eʺɱ, bǮ Bʮ bɱ{ɨ] |Oɨ, bV] bɱ{ɨ] |Oɨ + c=] Bʮ bɱ{ɨ] |Oɨ* 1983 84 xxɱ bɱ{ɨ] Eʺɱ < i {ɮ SS < l E xxɱ ʽɱɪx bɱ{ɨ] {ʱɺ x< VB* iiEɱx Vx b E n b. B.Vb. Eʺɨ E +vIi BE ʨi E M`x E Mɪ l* = ʨi x ʺɡʮ E E xl ]x ʽɱɪx Eʺɱ x< VB* Ex +V iE = {ɮ E< EɪǴɽ xɽ {< * < i E E Vɤ iE ɹ]Ҫ iɮ {ɮ xxɱ ʽɱɪx bɱ{ɨ] b E M`x xɽ E Vi, iɤ iE ɮ ɨɺ+ E ɨvx xɽ M* Sɽ xSɱ iɮ {ɮ +xE b M`i E n, Sɽ ʴEɺ ʨiɪ x n, Ex ExpҪ iɮ {ɮ <xE ɨI Ex xii +ɴɶE *

ɽ ɮ ʱB M E ʴɹɪ E iǨx |vx j xxҪ +] ʤɽɮ V{ E n ʽɱɪ E ʱB ʴɶ | * <ɺ {ɽc ɺx ɱ M BE +ɶ E Eh VM E +x ɱ ɨɪ =xE ɨɺ+ E +ɶ ɨvx M*

n E {ɽc Ij n E]Mɮ ] MB * BE i V {ɽc V , Vɺɨ Vɨ-EҮ, ʽSɱ |n, ʺEE, Pɱɪ, h{֮, j{֮, +hSɱ |n, ʨV +i , ɽ E ɦ E Eֱ ʨɱE 21 ƺn Sx Vi * {ɱ E]Mɮ ]] Ei * <xE 90 |iɶi ExpҪ ɽɪi E { ʶ n Vi + 10 |iɶi @h E { n Vi * VɤE +x |i E 30 |iɶi +lE ɽɪi +xnx E { n Vi + 70 |iɶi @h E { n Vi * EU ɨɪ {ڴ iE V <x |i E xx{b BE{bSɮ i l, ɽ ExpҪ ɮEɮ ɽx Ei l, = <] +ɡ E n Vi l* Ex x ʴii +ɪM E `x E n V {ɽc Ij E ʴv ʨɱi l, ɽ ʴnc E M<* ɺɰ{ |i +lE E] E P , EE <xE +ɪ E vx ʨi * <xE Vix +ɪ , ɽ ɽ E ESʮ E ix nx Sɱ Vi + ʴEɺ Eɪ EU xɽ S {i*

nںɮ E]Mɮ {ɽc Ij , VxE ʽ Bʮ bɱ{ɨ] |Oɨ E +iMi ʱɪ Mɪ ,

ɽ䶴ɮ Vɮ Vɺɨ =iiɮ |n E x Vɱ +i + Vɽ Sɮ ƺn SxE +i * +ɨ E n Vɱ + n ƺn SxE +i * {ʶSɨ Mɱ nVʱM Vɱ + iʨɱxb xұMɮ Vɱ +i * Vɽ BE-BE ƺn SxE +i * <E +iʮEi, +Mɮ Mɱi xɽ E i , ]x P] 159 iɱE +i *

Vɽ iE {ɽc Ij E Ƥv , |Ei E +ɴ EU ɨɺɪ + vɪ ʴɮɺi ʨɱ , VɺE ɺɰ{ i Eɮh ʴEɺ E Ij nx Ij {Uci V * +x Eɮh E l-l E-E +iʱi ʴEɺ =Oɴn E Vx ni * ɦɴ {ɽc x ɱ M xi|ɪ i , Ex ɽ nJ Mɪ E Vɽ-Vɽ =Oɴn {n + , Vɽ-Vɽ M x BV]x EB , =x |xi E ʱB ɨɪ-ɨɪ {ɮ {EV ʨɱi * xɩ xɴnx E <x {ɽc |xi E ɮ xxҪ nx nMi Vxi >{ɮ =`E S* {ɽc Ij Ƥvi i ʤxn+ E + nx E vx nx Sɽi *

|lɨ ʤxn - ɮ E`x MʱE ʺli B |iEڱ ɨ {ɽc E xɱ Mɽ * Sɽ >S {ɽc >S S^x, <x lx {ɮ ʴEɺ E Eɪ Ex ɮ xɽ * =nɽh E ʱB, BE ESS cE xEɱx i E E E ix J {ɪ |i E] JS + Vi , VɤE nx Ij +Mɮ cE E xɨh Ex , i ix J {B E E 5-6 E] cE x Ei * Vɽ iE ɨ E Ƥv , {ɽc +xE Ij B , V n E ɨ E M E] Vi * +x-Vx E E< vx xɽ i * =nɽh E ʱB, ʽSɱ

|n E ɽ-i Ij Sxɴ Ij {ci , < Ij ɡ {cx ʽJhb E ]]x MɦM U:-i ɽ iE ɨ{E E] Vi * B ʺli |xi E ɮEɮ E E{] uɮ ʴǺ ְ EE ɽ E M E ʱB ʴvɪ |nx Ex {ci *

Vɽ iE ɨ{E cE E Ƥv , {ɽc Ij M E ʱB cE i x< M< , Ex =xE {EE Ex E ɨɺ * ɮ {ɺ +lE vx ʨi * ɽ ii E {ɽc x ɱ M Vɤ ֤ɽ xɽ E Eɨ {ɮ Vi + ɨ E {ɺ ]i , i =xE ʺɮ {ɮ <ix vڱ {c i E Vɤ iE +{x ƽ x v , iɤ iE =xE vɨ{ix =xE {ɽSx xɽ {i * <ʱB xɴnx , cE E xɨh E ʱB +Mɮ ʶ +ɤn E +vɮ {ɮ n Vi + MʱE ʺli E xɽ nJ Mɪ, i {ɽc |xi {Uci Sɱ VɪM*

nںɮ ʤxn - {ɽc E ʴɺii Ijɡ B E VxɺJ* {ɽc V E Eֱ Ijɡ 4061.74 Eɮ E] + VxɺJ n Ec E `i * =iiɮ |n E x {ɽc Vɱ * +Mɮ Mɱi xɽ E , i <xE Ijɡ MɦM 52 Vɮ Eɮ E] `i + VxɺJ Eɱ 60 J * {{ֱx bʺ] E-E i 40-50-60 {ɮ-Eɮ E] `i *

ɽ䶴ɮ ʺƽ Vɮ ʽSɱ |n E VxViҪ Ij E Ijɡ 23,655 Eɮ E] * ɽn, +{E vɨ nx E vx ɽ x SɽM E {{ֱx E V bʺ] {ɮ-Eɮ E] , =ɨ 20 + 25 M * ʽSɱ |n E Eֱ Ijɡ 55,000 Eɮ E] `i * < Ij E VxEɮ nx Sɽi , 32,000 Eɮ E] E |ixvi < nx Ei * < 32,000 Eɮ E] 23,655 Eɮ E] ix VxViҪ Ij E ʱB * Vɺɨ {ɽ ɽ-i, Exx + ɮ +i * <x Ij {{ֱx E bʺ] 15 + 30 +vE xɽ `i *

ɽn, iҺɮ ʤxn ɽ E +ɪ E ʨi vx * ʱB ɽ |ɺxxi E ʴɹɪ E i E֨ɮ V ɽ ʴɮVɨx , V E Jt B +{i j + ɨ + iE ʽSɱ |n E J j * Vɽ iE {ɽc |i E ɴɱ , ʴɶE ʽSɱ |n E i EM* |Ei x c =nɮi ɤ EU n * Z n E i E֨ɮ V E Ei l E B {x n , V ʤVɱ {n Ex E Iɨi Ji * B {ilɮ n , Vɺɺ Ҩ] x Ei * |EiE xn B n Vɺɺ x Eɱ n ʱE ʴn {ɪ]E +i , Ex +ɪ E ʨi vx x ɽ BE B |n V |Ei E nʹ] +Ү Ex ɽ x ɱ M MɮҤ * +Mɮ =nɮi Exp ɽɪi ʨɱ i ɽ {ɽc |i, ʴɶE ʽSɱ |n V |i +ixɦǮ x Ei *

ɽn, Vɽ iE ʴti =i{nx E Ƥv , +V +E ʽSɱ |n 22,200 Mɴ] ʤVɱ {n Ex E Iɨi Ji Ex ʨi vx x E Eɮh + iE Eɱ 800 Mɴ] ʤVɱ E nx E * + V xɨhvx VxB =ɺ 2200 Mɴ] + ʤVɱ {n VBM, Ex 19,200 Mɴ] E ʱB { E Vɰi * iǨx ɮEɮ E v< nx SɽM, V | E֨ɮ vڨɱ V E xii ʽSɱ |n Sɱ * ʽSɱ |n E BE ɽiEI Vɱ ʴti {ʮVx , VɺE xɨ {ɴi Vɱ ʴti {ʮVx + =E xɨh BxBS{Һ Ex V , V 2051 Mɴ] ʤVɱ {n Ex E Iɨi Ji * |vxɨj V E +ɦɮ |E] Ex SɽM, <E |vxɨj V E E-Eɱ uɮ 12 nɨɮ E ʴvɴi { ʶɱxɺ VBM* Vɽ iE {ilɮ E Ƥv , V x E E B {ilɮ n , Vɺɺ Ҩ] x Ei * Ex Vɤ Ҩ] E EɮJx E i Ei i {ɪǴɮh E i + Vi * <E ɮ BE i EM, ɽ ɽ E +Mɮ <x {ɽc VMɱ E]M i x Eɱ {ɽc |i E xEx M ʱE V xS E nx Ij =x Ii E ɨx Ex {cM* Vɽ <x VMɱ E Sx E ɮ nʪi ɽ Exp ɮEɮ E nʪi xi E B |i E +vE +vE I E VB* =xE +vE +vE +lE ɽɪi n VB* x ɨ{n ɮ ʱB +ɪ E BE vx l, Ex 1980 , Vɤ ] b EVɮx BE] +ɪ =x E-E ɮ ʱB +xE ɨɺB {n E n, Sɽ ʽSɱ |n, {ڴiiɮ V +x E< {ɽc |i * x MɦM ix |Eɮ E i *

uɮ Vɮ

ɽ䶴ɮ ʺƽ Vɮ BE bɮE]b VMɱ , nںɮ ʮVɴ VMɱ + iҺɮ lb-E VMɱ * Ex ʥ] Eɱ Vɤ ] ]ɨ] + i =xx BE + h x< Vɺ iiҪ x ʨ E Mɪ* <E +l E ɽ x i xɽ Ex ɽ x-M ʨ * < ɤɺ c ɨɺ Jc Mɪ* +Mɮ Eڱ E ʱB ɴx E xɨh Ex , U]-U] ʴEɺ Eɪ Ex i E +{E ʱB ʨ xɽ * Eɮh ɽ E V ʨ Jɱ {c < ɽ iiҪ x ʨ Sɽ =ɨ BE I x * Vɤ ]ƺɡ E ʱB E< E Vi i BE +{ii Mi E Eix {c M B * Vɤ =xE iɪ Vi E BE {c xɽ i E Vi E x-ʨ i {c i M * +{E vɨ j ɽn xɴnx Ex SɽM E <x ʨɪ E ʮ-+<b]ʡEx Ex E +ɴɶEi *

EU Mƴ V VMɱ Pɮ B * +Mɮ <x Mƴ E <n-Mn VMɱ i =xE ɽ ɺ M E Vi * E< VMɱ M E ɽM E ʤx iɮ xɽ i * Vɤ Mƴ E M E ڱɦi ʴvB xɽ ʨɱi i E =`i E E x VMɱ {ɱ* <xE Eɮh ڱɦi ʴvB xɽ ʨɱi * <ʱB VMɱ E l ɺ B M E ʱB +{ cE xB* +Mɮ E xɨh ʴɦM xɽ xɴx i Exp ɮEɮ <E ʱB E< xɪɨ xB iE x ʴɦM E vɨ E E =x ɨ{E cE i ʨɱ*

+V VMɱ Vxɴɮ E gi J <x {ɽc |i i+ + ɽx E ʱB BE ɨɺ x Mɪ * ɽ ɮ n E ɨɺ Ex {ɽc |i ɽ + ʴE] ɨɺ * <ʱB < iɮ j V E vx +Eʹi E Vx E +ɴɶEi *

ɦ{i ɽn : <E ʱB n P] xvʮi + +{E i 20 ʨx] Vn ɨɪ Mɪ * +{E E xɽ , Ex ɦ xxҪ n <ɨ M E, <ʱB +{ Q ɨ{i E* g {S V nںɮ ʴɹɪ x *

ɽ䶴ɮ ʺƽ (b) : ɦ{i V, iҺɮ ʤn {ɮ * Sɮ-{S ʨx] ɨ{i E nM* iҺɮ i {ɪ]E E ɮ Ex Sɽi * ɮ ɽ iɪi E vx |ɪ: iɱ {ʮɽx * i xɨ j E * ɽ BE ii E E nʹ] +Mɮ EU ʨɱ i ʥ] ]< E ʨɱ + * Sɽ EɱE-ʶɨɱ <x E i {`x E] VMxp xMɮ ɴ <x E i * x 1924 E VMxp xMɮ <x E Eֱ iE, Z֤ {ɺ E xS ]xɱ xE Vx E ɴIɹ + l* +V V ] ]x nVʱM Sɱi =E ɱi ɽ E ]x E Mɪ E Jɮɤ x E Vɽ J P]i V * V M Jɮɤ <, =E =`E Ex E , ɽ ʺɱʺɱ Sɱ * {ɽ ʺEE Mɱ J iE Vi l* + Eɱ ʺɱMb iE Vi * E< M xɪ xɽ x + 46 E] E ɴ ]E ɨ{i Mɪ *

ʽSɱ +ɨx {ʮix E i E< ɮ =` SE + E< ɮ xxҪ jɪ x ɪn EB + E E MV {ʮix VBM* xxҪ i E֨ɮ V E |ɪɺ BE EMc Ex Sɱ * + Ei E =ɺ +ɪ xɽ i <ʱB ɽ ɪɤɱ xɽ * Vɤ ɽ Mc ]-E E jɪ E ʱB M i +ɪ i E M * <ʱB <E ɮ Sx E +ɴɶEi *

Vɽ iE Bɮ-ʴǺV E ɴɱ , +V ix <-{^ ʽSɱ |n Ex ix E ʺli +SU xɽ * Vɤ iE xɪʨi { <] xɽ SɱM, iɤ iE xɪʨi { {ɪ]E xɽ +ɪM* l ɽ <ix ɽM E x{ɱ Vx ɺi Ex ʽSɱ Vx +V ɽM *

uɮ Vɮ

ɽ䶴ɮ ʺƽ Vɮ Vɤ iE ʤVb<Vb ] xɽ M iɤ iE {ɪ]E <x Ij xɽ VBM* <ʱB < i E + vx nx E +ɴɶEi *

Vɽ iE Sl ʤxn E ɴɱ , ɽ J {ʮE Exp Oɨh Ij E +ivE nڮ x E Eɮh xx +lE Miʴvɪ E Eɮ Ij ʴEɺ v Ij E ʴEɺ v +i * b <ix nڮ E ={V E Sx nEEi +i * Vɤ iE ]ƺ{] ʤb xɽ n VBM, +{x =i{nx E ɽ iɮE E] iE xɽ {ɽS EM* EʱM Sx E ɴɺl Ex E +ɴɶEi iɦ <x {cɽ E ={V Sɽ ɽ ESɮ , +x SV , {ʮɱ Mb E] iE EM*


[NEXT PAGE]