<b>XIII LOK SABHA DEBATES, <i> Session II (Winter Session) </i> </b>
XIII LOK SABHA DEBATES, Session II (Winter Session) Wednesday, December 8, 1999/Agrahayana 17, 1921 (Saka )


Type of Debate: SHORT DURATION DISCUSSION (RULE -193)
Title: Discussion regarding problems being faced by farmers in various parts of the country raised by Shri Ram Nagina Mishra on the 7th December, 1999. (Concluded).

TEXT :

ɦ{i ɽn : + xɪɨ 193 E iɽi Ex E ɨɺ {ɮ SS M* |ɦxl ʺƽ E ɹh Vɮ l, E{ɪ {ڮ E*

|ɦxl ʺƽ (ɽɮVMV, ʤɽɮ) : ɦ{i V, Ex E nJ + {c {ɮ E < nx SS * + ʤɽɮ E ɨɱ {ɮ l* VE i l E Exɱ Vx E Eɮh Ex E n nx * Ex E g, Jc + Vɱ Vɨɴ E ɨɺ E ɮ ix Sɽi *

ɦ{i ɽn, g + Vɱ Vɨɴ E i Eɱ BE E E Ei Ex Ex E {c BE E ɨ{i xɽ i* ɽ U: ɽx {ʮɨ Ei i Ex ii g + Vx E Eɮh Ex E +Mɱ =n ɨ{i Vi * < |Eɮ Vɱ Vɨɴ Ex E {c * Vɽ iE Jc E |ɶx , ʤɽɮ <ɺ Sx E ʱɪ E< ɴɺl xɽ E M< * JɺE V ɮEɮ E V ]ڤɴ Mɪ Mɪ , =xɨ 1 |iɶi Eɨ xɽ E * <E BE Eɮh i ʤVɱ E E + nںɮ JɮJɴ E +ɴɺl* < Eɮh ɮEɮ E ɮ ]ڤɴ Mɪ * <ʱɪ Eʹ j Vb xɴnx EM E ʤɽɮ g Sx E ʱɪ + Jc x{]x E ʱɪ il Vɱ Vɨɴ ɽi nx E ʱɪ +{ Exp E BE ]Ҩ ɽ V + < ɤ E ɨI Eɪ* ʤɽɮ < ɨɱ Mɶɱ E ɽ 11-12 ʨxɺ] Exp + ƪM Eʹ il ʴii j ʤɽɮ *

nx ʤɽɮ +i * ʤɽɮ E {c Vix EM, =ɺ E xxҪ j xɽ Vxi * < ɨɪ Sɮ iɮ ʤɽɮ nJ< n * <ʱB EM E j V Exp ]Ҩ ʦVɴE <E ɨI EB + ʤɽɮ E M E ɽi nɴB* nںɮ i ʤVɱ E] E ɮ Ex Sɽi * +{ ʤɽɮ E ʤVɱ j SE * 117 Mƴ E VS Ҥ+< E E֨ɮMɱɨ ɽ x n * ɽ +{E Wɨx E nںɮ E Wɨx E , ɽ EMW {ɮ + VS {i SɱM* ʤɽɮ ʤVɱ E Eɨ EMW {ɮ + + Mƴ EMW {ɮ ʤVɱ Vɱ n M< * +{ S Ei E Ji {x E ʱB ʤVɱ E ={ɱɤv x ɱ * < iɮ bWɱ E V ڱ g , <ɺ Ex E {c g * bWɱ E ڱ gx {ɮ x xxҪ |vx j V + ɮEɮ +x֮v E l E Sɮ {ɪ E ɮ Ex {ɮ ɽi c ɮ + SɽM E =ɨ ɮE ʤb n + ɮEɮ +Mɮ ʤb nM i Mi E Ex E ɽi ʨɱM* {ɽ M E ɽ |Jb Jɱɪ E vɨ Ex E V + Jn ֽ E< Vi l* + {i xɽ V ɮEɮ E E E Vɽ ExpҪ ɮEɮ E xn E Vɽ V + Jn xɽ V {i , <ʱB ɽ Ex E ={ɱɤv xɽ {i *

BE Eʹ j V Ex E V ɺɪxE Jn i , {S-i ɱ iE i ɱ E ɽi ={V ni , Ex B Jn x SʽB Vɺɨ ɪx E j E * <ʱB EE xE Sɱi + JɺE Mƴ E Ex E Ex E {S-i ɮ iE Ji ɺɪxE Jn bɱi i =E n ʨ^ E =Ǯ Ei E Vi * <ʱB B Jn E xɨh E ʱB +{x Eʹ YxE E E Vɺɨ ɪx E j E + ʨ^ E =Ǯ Ei x *

ɽn, Eʹ j V Ex Sɽi E ɽ {ڴ < ʴɦM E Eʹ j i* +{x U{ɮ Eʹ ʴɦM E +xֺvx Exp l{i Ex E Ph E l* = ɨɪ < nx E n xɽ l + + +{E |ɨx Mɪ* +{ V iɮ E j Eʤx] iɮ E j x MB Ex U{ɮ ɽ Eʹ E nVB*

ɮ ʤɽɮ ɽi iɮ E Ji i * E +SU Ji i * Vɡ{֮ E< iɮ E E Ji E ʱB |ʺr , V{֮ E E ʱB |ʺr * ʤɽɮ ʤVɪ ɽi i * ɽ +ɱ + {V E Ji i , Sɴɱ, M + <J E Ji i Ex Ex E Vɤ ɱ =Mi i Eb ]V c j ={ɱɤv xɽ Vɽ Ex +ɱ-{V E J E* V |<] Eb ]V ɱ , ɽ {ɽ Ex ְ E ni E ɮ ɽ VMɽ xɽ , ]V ɮ Mɪ * <ɺ Ex E ɱ E xEx i * SɽM E Eb ]V ɮEɮ iɮ {ɮ JֱɴB i Ex E ʱB ɽi c Eɨ M, ɽi c ={ɱʤv M* Ex E ʱB ʤb ɽi SV {ɮ ʨɱi * {ɽ {{M ] E ʱB ʤb ʨɱi l, ʮM E {<{ E ʱB ʨɱi l* BE i Ex ʤSʱɪ uɮ {ɮx i , ʤb E ɨɱ E Eɡ {ɮx i * ɮ ɽ ʨ ʴEɺ E * +{ + j V Vxi E Ex E ʱB {ʨ{M ] + +x iɮ E ɨx E ʱB ɽ @h ֽ Ei l, Ex + V VxEɮ ʨɱ E Ex n-n E `E Ji + Ei E x i E @h xɽ ʱɪ + 25,000 {ɪ E ɮ] <Ǻ SE *

= E <ix P{ɱ + E Vɽ +{ Ex E ɽi nx E ʱB E @h ֽ Ex E i Ei l, ɽ {ɮ +V Ex =ix @h E ɮ] + {ʱɺ E b Pɮ UcE M ʡi * =xE ɴ iE JE lx Vɪ V * =xE Ji-c xұɨ E ʺli {ɽS * <x ɤ ʤn+ {ɮ VS Ex E +ɴɶEi + SɽM E <xE VS EE +{ +ɴɶE EɮǴ< E* <E l ɽ Ex Sɽi E ɽi B ɱ i Vx Ex {V Ex E ʱB Mi * Ex E< Ҩɮ Vi VɺE {ɽSx Mƴ + ni xɽ { * +V ʤɽɮ Ec {ɪ E Ҷɨ E {c ɮn SE * {c iɮ , {i xɽ E J Vi * Ex ɽ lxҪ Eʹ ʴɦM ɨ{E Ex {ɮ {i xɽ Sɱi E <x {c Ex Ҩɮ * Ex Ҷɨ E {c ʺɡ { Ex E ʱB Mi * Si E V Vɨx +ʺSi , =ɨ Ҷɨ E {c ME { E Ei * Ex =xE ɮ Mi, ɮ {ʮɨ + ɮ xi Eɮ SE + Ҩɮ E + iE {i xɽ Sɱ E *

ɦ{i ɽn, ɮEɮ E Mɱi xiɪ E Eɮh Ex E n ʤn+ {ɮ Eɡ E`x< * SEn E Eɨ ʤɽɮ ְ + l* VxɺJ i gi Sɱ V , Ex Vɨx E ɨ<-Sc< xɽ g * VxɺJ gx E Vɽ Ji E ]ɮ ]Ec + Ji VMɽ x x E Eɮh Ex E Ji Ex Eɡ +ʴv i * SEn M<* <ʱB Sɽi E +{ V ɮEɮ E xn nVB E SEn E ɴɺl Eɪ* SEn Mi E +xV E {nɴɮ Eɡ gM*

ɦ{i ɽn, Ex E BE + ɨɺ -nn E * -nn Ex E Eɡ {c + {ɮx * ɽ ix Sɽi E Vɨx E nn +ɮV E +vɮ {ɮ E Vi V xVɮ E =Si xɽ i* Vɨx +M-+M ֱE +M-+M VMɽ {ɮ * BE iɮ ɽ E Vɨx , BE iɮ ʺSi Vɨx , BE iɮ +ʺSi Vɨx + nںɮ nɮ Ij E Vɨx i * =E ڱ ɽi E i * ɽ Sɽi E -nn +ɮV E +vɮ {ɮ xɽ, Vɨx E ڱ E +vɮ {ɮ x SʽB* n +ɮV E +vɮ {ɮ Ex i Eʹ j V EM E Sʱɪ +{x ɽ nɮ E n BEc Vɨx -nn +{E nɴ nM + ɮ ʱB +{ <E_ Vɨx Snx SE nɴ n* +{ = Vڮ xɽ EM* <ʱB Vɨx V -nn x SʽB ɽ xʶSi i {ɮ +ɮV E +vɮ {ɮ xɽ ʱE =E ڱ E +vɮ {ɮ x SʽB*

ɦ{i ɽn, Mxx Ex E {c E Ƥv ix Sɽi * ʤɽɮ + =iiɮ |n Mxx E Ji ɽi +vE j i * Ex + E l Ex {ci , {i xɽ ɮi ɮEɮ E ʴii jɱɪ + hV jɱɪ E xҪi E * ɮ n Vɤ i J ]x Sx Vn , =E n {Eix V n Sx E +ɪi Ei * {i xɽ ɽ ʨj n nֶx n * EɮMɱ E n {i Sɱ Mɪ * Ex = n Sx E +ɪi Ei * < ɨɱ {Eix E xҪi E ɨZx SʽB E Vix =E Mi , =ɺ E nɨ {ɮ ɽ Sx ֽ Ei * Ei E Sx ɽ <ʱB M SE EҨi E ʺlɮ Jx * Ex EҨi ʺlɮ Jx E nֹ{ʮhɨ ɮ +lǴɴɺl {ɮ {cx ɱ , ɮ Sx =tM {ɮ {cx ɱ , ɮ Mxx E Ji {ɮ {cx ɱ * {Eix Sɽi E ɽ +{x Sx ʽnֺix ɺi nɨ {ɮ V* iE ɽ E Mxx Ex Mxx E Vn Ji x E E, ɽ E Sx =tM n VB* <ʱB Ex Sɽi E Sx E V +ɪi i ɽ x ɮ +lǴɪɴɺl E nʹ]Eh `E , x ɽ Ex E ʽi `E , x ɽ Sx =tM Ex ɱ E ʱB `E * <ʱB B ɴɺl xɽ x SʽB, B ɴɺl ɽ xE Sɱi E <ɺ < n E xEx x ɱ *

ɦ{i ɽn, ʴɶ { ix Sɽi E gɴɮ Ex{֮ Mɮ ʨɱ E BE Sx ʨɱ l* = {ɮ Ex E i ɹ Ec {ɪ Eɪ * E Ex ciɱ Ei , E vɮx {ɮ `i * b V ɽ ` B * Ex Vɤ BE ɮ ciɱ Ei i <xE BE Sxɴ {ɮ E Vi * Ex Ex E { E Mix + iE xɽ { * + VxEɮ ʨɱ E =iiɮ |n E E j E l Ex{֮ Mɮ ʨɱ E S n Mɪ + j V Mɮ ʨɱ E Sɱx ɱ i xɽ Si *

ɦ{i ɽn, =ɺ {]Ǻ, E-{֮V JE V * {V SE +ɨnx E * +V U: Ec {ɪ Ex E Eɪ =E E M* nx Ex E Vɺ fM nx ɽ ɤE ɨx * ʤɽɮ ɤ Sx ʨɱ xn * < iɮ =iiɮ |n xn * <ʱB EM E Sx ʨɱ E Sɱx E ɴɺl E VB* Mxx Ex E |iɽx n VB* Ex E ɤʺb E +x vɨ Ex E xɱ gx E Eɨ E* fɴɮ Sx ʨɱ {ɮ Ex E U: Ec {ɪ Eɪ * +{E Exx n iEi , i <E ɺi xEɱ + Ex E Eɪ E Mix EB*

ɦ{i ɽn, BE-n Zɴ ɽ nx Sɽi E V @h Ex E ֽ Eɪ Vi =E n ɽi ʱɪ Vi * ɽ Ex E ʽi xɽ * n E n xxiɨ x SʽB + l Ex +{x ɱ n E< =tM vv Sɱx Sɽ, i = =E +x֨i n Vx SʽB* V n E< Ex +{x uɮ {n E M< iɱɽx i xEɱx Sɽ, i = +x֨i n Vx SʽB* < |Eɮ n E< Ex +{x Vں xEɱx Sɽ, i =E =tM{iɪ E Vɺ |Eɮ E V n {ɮ @h n Vi = |Eɮ =x @h nx SʽB* <ɺ Eɮ E ɨvx M + Ex E +ɪ gM* Vɤ Ex +lE nʹ] Vɤi M i n Vɤi M* B E nx E n E +l ɴɺl Vɤi i n Vɤi M, <ɺ Eɨ xɽ SɱM* Vɤ iE Ex E +lE ʺli Vɤi xɽ M, iɤ n Vɤi xɽ Ei*

ɦ{i ɽn, +{E vɨ ɽ M Ei E Eʹ E =tM E nV n VB* <ɺ Ex E +ɪ gM + xɱ gM* + Ex E ɱ E V ڱ xvʮi E Vi =E ɮ Ex Sɽi * ɽ n Bɮ EbҶb Eɮ `E Ex E =i{nx E ڱ =x M uɮ iɪ E Vi Vxx E Ex E nJ xɽ, Ji E nJ xɽ, {x E ni , nJ xɽ* Ex E |n V {nɴɮ i ɽ +M-+ɺ fM i VɺE EҨi +M-+M i * V JS lx-lx E ʽɤ +M-+M * <ʱB M E |i ɹ Ex E ڱ xvʮi Ex i V ڱ +ɪM =ɨ Ex E |ixv ʨɱ EB VB iE =E +xֺɮ ɽ E {ʮɨ, ɽ E Mi E +xֺɮ ɽ E Ex E {nɴɮ E ڱ iɪ E E + ڱ iɪ Ei ɨɪ Mi B xɡ E ʽɤ M EE ڱ iɪ EB VB V =tM EB Vi * +{x x E ʱB ɨɪ n <E ʱB +{E vxɴn*

֤v ɪ (Mɱ{֮) : ɦ{i ɽn, +{E |i ɽi EiY E +{x Z n E ʴʦxx M Ex Vx ɨɺ+ VZ =xE ɮ x E E |nx E * ɽn, +V Vɤ E ɮ n ɽjɤn x + <EEҺɴ iɤn Vx E ʱB {ڮ iɮ ii{ɮ + +{x +Vn E 50 ɱMɮ E Vɶx x SE + +{x iɮEE E ɮ ɽi ɮ i E ,

Ex ɮ ʨj x V =iiɮ |n E, ʤɽɮ E + +x VMɽ E Ex E ɨɺ E VF E, Sɽ Mxx =i{nE , V] =i{nE , +x +xV E =i{nx Ex ɱ +x ɨx E =i{nx Eɪ M , =xE ʺli ɽi ɪɴɽ, nnxE + ɨxE * +V ɤɺ MƦҮ |ɶx ɽ E +Jɮ Ex xiɪ ɮ n E Ex E E x SʽB* ɮ n E Ex +V {ڮ ʴEɺ E Z =`E ɨ{h ɮi E BEi, +Jbi, +Vn, ɴǦʨEi, +ʺii + +ʺi E |iE x B *

1821 V ( ɺn +Sɪ {`ɺx B)

Ex + E i E + iE < n V |ɪɺ E Vx SʽB, ɽ xɽ + * + iE V Sxɪ ʨɱ , V P]xɪ P] , V +w |n, Ex]E, ɽɮɹ], {Vɤ +n V ɮ Ex x c {x {ɮ +iɽiɪ E * +iɽiɪ E{ɺ E Ex x ... (ɴvx)

ɦ{i ɽn : +{ BE ʨx] E EE ƺnҪ Eɪ j E EU Ex *

THE MINISTER OF PARLIAMENTARY AFFAIRS AND MINISTER OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY (SHRI PRAMOD MAHAJAN): Sir, I want to make a submission. As it was decided in the BAC, we have to complete this subject today. There are many Members who want to speak, and we do not mind sitting late, whatever time it takes. So, if the Members wish, then we can extend the time. We will make arrangements for dinner around 8.00 p.m. or 8.30 p.m.

MR. CHAIRMAN: So, is it the sense of the House that we should sit till this subject is over?

SEVERAL HON. MEMBERS: Yes.

MR. CHAIRMAN: Thank you.

֤v ɪ (Mɱ{֮) : ɽn, ɽi +xɴҪ P]xɪ ɮ ɽ < VɺE Sɱi ɮ =x Ex E +{x VҴx ұ E MƦҮ iɶ + xɮɶ ɨ{i E nx {c * Eɮh E ? Eɮh ɽ E =xE >{ɮ EV E Z g , =xE ɱ ɮ M< , =xE +{x ɱ E ɦEɮ ڱ xɽ ʨɱ , =xE ɱ E bɮh E E< ɴɺl xɽ il =xE ɱ E g, E iɤɽ EEɮh nJ ɽVx E SMɱ ƺx E ʱB Ex Vɤڮ i * n E c {x {ɮ Z + Ҩi Ex , MɮҤ Ex VxE <E ʶEɮ x {c *

< ɨɱ Eʹ j V Ex SɽM E Vɤ ɽ Vɴɤ n iɤ BE B {ɹ] xi E Ph E iE Vɺ ɨɺ E VF x E =E Eɮh +<n < n E E< Ex +iɽi xɽ EM*


[NEXT PAGE]