By unearthing a fresh material evidence, a party should be allowed to file an Additional Written Statement for which an amendment has been sought. A time-limit has to be prescribed. There is Section 105 of the Limitation Act.

MR. CHAIRMAN: A time-limit of 10 minutes has been prescribed for your party. Now, you have taken 14 minutes.

SHRI M.V.V.S. MURTHI (VISAKHAPATNAM): That is why the cases are piling up in the courts. ... (Interruptions)

SHRI T.M. SELVAGANPATHI : I will wind up in a minute. I would like to draw the attention of the hon. Minister to Section 5 of the Limitation Act. It gives ample powers to the Judicial Officers. I know that there are suits in which a party gets ex parte order and he has been sleeping for almost two years. After two years, he files a petition to set aside the ex parte order and that ex parte order is also set aside after two years and subjected to litigation.

Again he goes as ex parte and maybe on some flimsy reasons he projects a petition and it is allowed in the Limitation Act. The hon. Minister may take a note of all these things and also a provision is made to award compensation on a punitive action in the injunction suit.

There are cases where legitimate demand is made. There are cases where responsible allegation is made. In such types of cases you cannot make it mandatory to provide compensation or provide punitive action. Therefore, it should be left to the discretion of the court.

With all this, my humble submission is that the Law Ministry instead of striving for a piecemeal legislation should do something. If it cannot be done now, it can never be done, if such is the menace now as far as civil litigation is concerned.

I welcome this Bill and say that a piecemeal legislation is brought before this House. I expect the Government to come with a comprehensive legislation. Thank you.

Sxp ڹh ʺƽ (Jɤn) : xxҪ +vɹ`i ɽn, +{x Z x E E n, <E ʱB +{E +ɦɮ * ɮ Mƴ BE Eɴi VɺE + xxҪ j V E vx +Eʹi Ex SɽM - { E Ex ] Mi* ɽ < ɨɪ xɪ E ɨɱ ʽnֺix * < ɨɪ n Ec +` J EʺV ʴʦxx E]Ǻ {bM + n֦M ɽ E Vɺ |n +i =E xɨ =iiɮ |n , ɽ E < E] Vn Ei 8,65,000 En {bM * ʺEE BE B V Vɺɨ j 99 EʺV {bM * Ex ɮ =iiɮ |n ɤɺ Vn n֦Mɶɱ Vɺɨ g +` J Vn EʺV {bM * V +{E E] x ʮ{] n =ɨ < E] E VVV E >{ɮ 1367 EʺV E BɮV +i * ɽ n֦M E ʽnֺix E ɴSS xɪɱɪ Һ Vɮ EʺV {bM * +ڨx BE En 10 15 ɹ E Ei Mi + B V ɤɺ c E`x< i ɽ ʴɶ i xɴnx Ex Sɽi * <ɨ Vɺ E E >{ɮ En Sɱi , =E ɨɪ + { ɮn i * i ɽ E VɺE {ɺ { i =E i Vɨxi Vi + Vɺ Sɮ E {ɺ { xɽ i , =E {ڮ ɨɪ V ii * <E xiV ɽ i E +{ɮv {ɪ JS EE U] Vi + ɽ +E {x: +{ɮv Ei * <ɨ ɤɺ c n֦M E i ɽ E Exx E |i M E ɪ E x M , VɺE Eɮh +{ɮv giɮ *

ɦ{i ɽn, ɽ ix Sɽi E < ɨɪ ʽnֺix Vix nҴx En , =xɨ ɮEɮ BE {I , Vxɨ 65 Һn EʺV ɮEɮ uɮ c V * <xɨ ɮEɮ +{x {I Ji xɽ + +ڨx ɽ nJ Vi E 90 Һn ɨɱ ɮEɮ En ɮi * < |Eɮ x ɽ nJ E V ʴɱɨ i =E J Eɮh ɮEɮ + ɮEɮ uɮ xʨi Eұ i * V +{x EʺV E { xɽ Ei + En E +M gi Sɱ Vi *

ɦ{i ɽn, +{E ɽ i nx =Si ɨZi E ʴMi nx ɮ ʨxɺ] ɽ x BE JE i E l E ɱiEɮ E ɨɱ ƺ E V n VB* +{ɺ xɴnx Ei E ɱiEɮ E j 15 20 Һn EʺV Vɺ] i + =xɨ +ڨx ʺɡ ix Һn EʺV V i * ɽn, Vx +b] Ex EU xx ɱ xɽ * +{ɺ xɴnx E <x EʺV E Vɱn BE{b<] Eɪ* n +n E Vɱn xɪ ʨɱx M i xʶSi xɪ E Vix Exx +{x x n , ʽnֺix E xɪ ɴɺl E Sɱx E ʱB {ɪ{i * E-E +{ {ɮ + +{E ɮEɮ E >{ɮ B nEEi +i ** Ex ɽ ɨɱ `b ɺi ʺɡ <ʱB {c + EE +{E l =xE +ɪƺ , +{E {] E l =xE E< +ɪƺ *

ɦ{i ɽn, Sɮ-{S Zɴ nx Sɽi *

... (ɴvx)

MR. CHAIRMAN : I appeal to the hon. Member not to mention the name of any former Member of the House.

SHRI CHANDRA BHUSHAN SINGH (FARRUKHABAD): Thank you, Sir. I withdraw my words.

ɦ{i ɽn, Sɮ-{S Zɴ nx Sɽi * E +nɱi E ɴɺl ɽi +SU + E +nɱi Sɱ * <xE + |ɦɴ xɪ VB, i ɽi ɮ En +ɺx x{] Ei * {ʮʮE ZMc E x{]x i n ʴɶ +nɱi E xɨh E n, i U]-] ɨɱ E x{]ɮ E V Ei * xʪE +vEɮ n ʴɱɨ Ei + ɽ |ɨhi VB E xʪE +vEɮ E Eɮh E En E ɱ ɨɪ {ɮ xɽ +, i =E M{xҪ Sʮjɴɱ =E =J E VB*

ɦ{i ɽn, ɽ xɴnx Ex SɽM E V ɮEɮ Eұ xʨi EB VB EiǴ-{ɮɪh + +{x EiǴ E |i VMɯE iE ɮEɮ ɨɱ +SU fM { E E E E Vɱn x{] E* <E l ɽn ɽ +ɴɶE E En E MEh E VB, iE V <{]] E , =xE Vɱn b{V-+ɡ E VB + Vɱn xɪ nɪ VB* <E l BE xɴnx + Ex SɽM E <E] E ɨx EM bV 180 i + E] Sɮ-{S P] Eɨ Ei , ɽ 8 P] EB VB* V +x ʺʴɱ ESʮ E ɨx ɴɺl VɺE +xֺɮ =x 8 P] Eɨ Ex i , E] E = E +xֺɮ 8 P] E Eɨ Ex SʽB, B ɴɺl E VB*

ɽn, |Ҩ E] MʨǪ n ɽx + nǪ 15 nx xn i * ɽ +OV E ɨɪ i `E l, EE n ֱE E l, =xE Mɨ Vn Mi l, Ex + E Eɱ +OV, x ʽxnֺixɪ E Mɨ Mi ? n B , i =x ʽxnֺix UcE ʴn Sɱ Vx SʽB* M E ɽ U^ ɱ ɴɺl xn x SʽB + Vɺ |Eɮ ʺʴɱ ʴǺ E ESɮ Eɨ Ei , x SʽB*

---------------------------------------------------------------

* +vI{` E +nxֺɮ EɪǴɽ ixi xEɱ n Mɪ*

ɦ{i ɽn, + |ɦ xl ʺƽ V x E E n +{x +l Eʨɶxɮ E Iɪ ʮEb Ex E ʱB xʨi E n + n Iɪ x M, `E xɽ M, ɽ i ʤɱEֱ `E * +l Eʨɶxɮ i ɽ Ei i VxE Eɱi xɽ Sɱi + VxE ɨ iE Sɪ E { xɽ ʨɱi* <ʱB +{ɺ +{ұ Ei E < |F E M x E* {ڴ xɪvҶ ɴɺS JV x BE i E l E BE xMɮx ʨi x< VB + =ɨ ɨEi |Ji xɪvҶ E ʨi x* iE M E <Ǩxnɮ xɪ ʨɱ E + <ɨ x ɱ ɹ]Sɮ E E V E* n B E] x n VBM, i xɪ E Ij x ɱ ɹ]Sɮ E Eɡ n iE E V EM + M E ɨx iɮE xɪ ʨɱ EM*

ɦ{i ɽn, +{E ɽi-ɽi F MVɮ E +{x Z x E ɨɪ n* <x Sxn Zɴ E l +{x i ɨ{i Ei * vxɴn*

|. ɺ ʺƽ ɴi (+Vɨ) : xɴɮ ɦ{i V, , ʴv j V uɮ nx |ɺii ʺʴɱ |F ʽi (ƶvx) ʴvE, 1999 E |ɤɱ ɨlx Ei * ʺʴɱ |F ʽi + ƶvx Ex E ʱB |ɺii E Mɪ * <E l-l ɽn ʺʴɱ |F ʽi, 1908 {ʮҨ +vxɪɨ, 1963 + xɪɱɪ ֱE +vxɪɨ, 1870 + ƶvx Ex ɱ ʴvE E |ɺii Ex E ɽ |ɪɺ E Mɪ *

Ex SɽM E BE EijE n + EhEɮ V E ʱB +ɴɶE E ɽ E Vxi E ɺi, ɽV, ֱɦ + Q xɪ ʨɱ E* Z Jn E l Ex |c E +V ɮ xɪ ɽM Mɪ * <ʱB +{E vɨ xxҪ ʴv j V E vx +Eʹi Ex SɽM E + ɨɪ + Mɪ + +{x ɪ Eɮ E E xʪE vɮ E +ii +ɴɶEi + xʪE vɮ E nʹ] , En E Vɱn x{]x E nʹ] + Vxi E xɪ Q ={ɱɤv Ex E ʱB Vɤ +{ ʺʴɱ |Vɮ Eb E +n <ix ƶvx E +ɪ i +{ɺ |lx EM E + xʪE +ɪM E M`x Q E Vɪ EE ɮ n E +n <E BE |Eɮ M =` *

Eij E ix +M -- Eɪ{ʱE, ʴvʪE + xɪ{ʱE* Vɤ ix +M E +n Sɰ { + ɨO { Eɪ Sʱi xɽ i , iɤ ɨV E +n E< x E< ʴbx {n Vi * +V Z Jn E l Ex {c E xɪ{ʱE xSɱ iɮ {ɮ V ɮ vMh E l E ɹ]Sɮ {i x M Mɪ + ɪ Eұ vx Ji E Ex Vɺ]] E `x ɱ =xE E Ei * < E] i x ɽ ʺli nJ E Ex VV ɽ ʴɮV, i +{x En =xE ɨx, =xE ʱɺ] + Vɪ, +xl = {ɮ iɮJ x E Eʶɶ Ei ]ɱx E Eʶɶ Ei * ɽ ʺli c ɪɴɽ *

+{x ʺʴɱ |Vɮ Eb E +n ƶvx x E ʱB Mɮ E ɦ M`i +vxɺl ʴvx Ƥv ʨi E ʺɡʮ E x , ɮi E ʴv +ɪM E 129 ʮ{] E vx J + xɪvҶ .B.ʱɨi E ʮ{] E Eɪxi Ex E nʹ] +{x <ɨ EU {ʮix E * Vɤ +{x <x ɮ E vx J i +{ɺ |lx Ex SɽM E + ɨɪ + Mɪ Vɤ ɮ Exx E {SnM E nڮ EE <x lc ɮEi E Vɪ iE Vxi E xɪ ɽV |{i E*

xɴɮ, ɮ < i E +x֦ɴ E Mƴ E MɮҤ nڮ c ME iɮJ {ɮ Vi i ɽ {i Mi E Eұ M ciɱ {ɮ * Eұ E ciɱ 15-20 nx BE-BE ɽx iE Sɱi * Ex Sɽi E Eұ E ʱB E< +Sɮ ʽi * =xE V Bʺɪx i , =xE iɮ iɪ x SʽB E +Mɮ ִEE Mƴ <ix Eɪ c ME iɮJ {ɮ ɮ-ɮ ={ʺli i , Vɺ]] ɽ =E ɮ-ɮ iɮJ ni + Eұ E ciɱ ɨ Sɱi i {ʮhɨɺɰ{ ɽ Sɮ Vɺx xɪ |{i Ex E ʱB xɪ E nɮ Vɮ i , = Eix {ɮx + +ʴv E ɨx Ex {ci * + ɮ ʨj E l--

Justice delayed is justice denied.

xɪ +Mɮ ʴɱƤ E Vi i ɨZ VB E xɪ <Eɮ E Vi *

ɦ{i V, ɽ Eɴi E

Justice hurried is justice buried. Justice hurried is justice worried.

+Mɮ xɪ Vɱn E Vi i EU SiVxE ʺli {n Vi * <ʱB nx SV E +n ɨxɪ x SʽB* +{x <ɨ V vɮ x E |ɪɺ E , =ɨ <x i E vx J * SɽM E vx, ɨɪ + Ei E ɤn xɪ |{i E +n E E *

< iɮ BE ʴvE ɽɪi x l* U] xɪɱɪ E +n cx E ʱB n MɮҤ E {ɺ { xɽ , =xE iɮ Eɱi Ex E ʱB, MɮҤ ɽɪi |{i E E* <E ʱB BE ʴvE ɽɪi ʨi Vɱ iɮ {ɮ x l* Ex Sɽi E =E lc Eiɶɱ xɪ Vɪ iE MɮҤ E +ɺx ɽɪi |nx E E* <E l xɪɱɪ E V ɴx , =xE ʺli lc nxҪ * =xE n vɮx E iɮ vx n Vɪ* ʱ]M] E ʱB b M V E] xx Sɽi , =xE xx E xɪɱɪ E iɮ +Y ʨɱ* xɪvҶ E J E lc gɪ Vɪ EE =xE +xE lx ʮEi * <xE iɮ vx +Eʹi Ei B < ʤɱ E {֮V ɨlx Ei + |lx Ei E ɴǺɨi < {ʮi E Vɪ* vxɴn*

MR. CHAIRMAN : Shri Pravin Rashtrapal - Not present.

Shri A.C. Jos - Not present.

Shri M.O.H. Farook - Not present.

1700 hrs.

֮ ɨɮɴ Vvɴ ({ɮx) : ɦ{i ɽn, Eb + ʺʴɱ |Vɮ (+b]) ʤɱ E + {] ɨlx Ei * < +b] ʤɱ {ɮ nx ʴɺiɮ SS < * Vɤ {x] E] ] nJɱ Ei , bxb] E Jɱɡ E< E nJɱ Ei , Sɽ + E] , b]E] E] , < E] |Ҩ E] , = Vɱn + <{ɶDZ Vʺ] ʨɱx Vɰ , <ɨ E< n ɪ xɽ * {ڮ ʽxnֺix < E], |Ҩ E] ɽi Vn E {bM * <E iɮ ɮEɮ E M Ex SʽB EE `

Justice delayed is justice denied'.

n xɪ ʨɱx n M< i xɪ ʨɱM, B xɽ Ei*

< ʤɱ E {ɹ` J 6 xɪɨ 14(3) E +iMi ʱJ - Vɽ < xɪɨ E +vx n {j E l E< niɴV =E |i < xɽ E Vi ɽ = n E xɴ< E ɨɪ n E + Iɪ Oɽh EB Vx E ʱB +xYi xɽ E VBM* Vɤ {x] bxb] E Jɱɡ E] ] nJɱ Ei , ɽi niɴV B i Vx ɽ ] nJɱ Ei ɨɪ ʺɱ xɽ E {i, n ʨɱ Ei * Exx j ʴxi Ei E Vɤ n ʽʮM E ʱB VB iɤ {x] E niɴV nJɱ Ex E +x֨i ʨɱ, < {ɮ M Ex SʽB*

+ E], < E] |Ҩ E] Exp ɮEɮ E En V ɮEɮ E En , Vn Vn ɮEɮ En ɮEɮ E Jɱɡ Vi , B E i , ɽ M Ex E i * n Vɤ E ʽʮM E ʱB +i i = E< bEڨ] nJɱ Ex E +x֨i x SʽB* <ix Zɴ nE +{x i ɨ{i Ei * ɽi-ɽi vxɴn*

b. Pִƶ |ɺn ʺƽ (ɱ) : ɦ{i ɽn, ɶɽڮ Vxi E ʴux |. ɺE x E E V Ei Vɺ ʴɹɪ E ʴɶY i , =E = ʴɦM E j x n Vɪ i ɽ ʴɡ Vi , Eɨ E Mcc ni *

ʴv, xɪ + E{x Eɪ j ( ɨ V`ɱx) : ɽ ɺE x xɽ E , +{x E *

... (ɴvx)

b. Pִƶ |ɺn ʺƽ : EʱB EM, ɺE x E , +{ <E Uxɤx E *

xɽ Sɽi * xxҪ Exx j xɨ Eұ * E< ɨɱ Vɤ E Eұ xɽ Ʀɱi i Ʀɱ i * E E Eұ xɽ ʨɱi i ɨɱ i * b +ɪM ɱ ɨɱ , +ɮIh ɱ ɨɱ M E iɮ , ɮEɮ E iɮ Eұ l* <xE EiǨx ɽi +SU , <ʱB +{I Ei E +SU-+SU Exx BM, Vɺɺ xɪ Vɱn ʨɱ E* MɮҤ +n E E JS ɱ xɪ Vɱn ʨɱM, xɪ ʤEM xɽ, xɪ S xɽ VɪM, xɪ Jɮn xɽ VɪM, xɪ ʨɱM, <xɺ B +{I Ei * SE Eʤɱ +n , <ɺ i +SU l E {ɽ Pɮ ɱ j l, +x bɱ{ɨ] ʨxɺ] E +SU j l, M E ɮ ʱJ-{g E l E B.{. M E Pɮ ʨɱ Vɪ, Ex + ʨɱx ɱ xɽ Mi , + = ʨxɺ] E j n Mɪ i M E xEx Mɪ* ƺnҪ Eɪ j x , B.{. M E Pɮ ʨɱx E ɨɱ +M g Mɪ l, Vɤ Exx j V = ɨɪ +x bɱ{ɨ] E j l* J, + nJM*


[NEXT PAGE]